Skip to main content

The COC say they are the only ones going to Heaven. Catholics say their way is the only way, the only true church. OSAS Baptist will tell you that you can be "always forever, never lose it", saved. 

 

Any that doesn't belong to any of those religions is apparently going to Hell. Since all of them can't be right, which one has it right?

I know what the COC, Catholics, & OSAS Baptist will say, I would love to hear the opinion of others.

 

I can just see God judging people. He has a sign on each side of his chair. One says Right (Heaven), the other says Wrong, (Hell) He doesn't say anything, just points to which side a person goes to. The Right & Wrong says it all.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Semi, IF there was a being that created us and the whole universe it would be aware of what our limitations are. There would be none of this judgement junk. There is no way there is some higher being that would have the capacity to create all the we know (and what we don't know yet) that would be as petty, evil, demanding, jealous, indecisive, and cruel as the one that is depicted in the bible. That God does not exist.

 

I also know what the different sects of Christians will say because we have heard it all before. What they can't explain is how this supposedly loving, caring, "father" would allow any of his "children" to be tortured for eternity. Instead they make the claim of "free will" as if anyone would choose such a thing. This God invented sin, then punished humans over and over for succumbing to these sins, then decided to clone himself to return to Earth in order to save his creation from himself by sacrificing himself to himself. Then we are given the task of still avoiding these pitfalls he puts in our path and if we fail again he will punish us for eternity by "allowing" us to go to a place of eternal torture. Yeah, there's a being I want to worship.

 

IF the God of the bible exist then I have yet to meet any human that could live up to the expectations required to spend eternity in heaven. IF that God exist he has set up humanity to fail.

 

However, I don't waste any time worrying about such a supernatural being. The only thing that we have to base a belief on this being is a book that is riddled with inconsistencies and misinformation. Not to mention it was written by men that could not even grasp the concept of a earth that wasn't flat. If I die and find myself in front of this being I think I have as good a chance of getting the right sign as any Christian I have ever met. Either way I don't stress it.

 

As you said, they all believe they are following the correct religion and they worship the true God, and as you said, they can't all be right. Since they are all using the same book to prop up their belief I have to dismiss it as unreliable. Otherwise it would be obvious to us all. Until this God shows up and introduces itself to me I will just go on facts and logic. Neither of which allow for a belief in a God in heaven sitting in judgement of his creations.

 

Originally Posted by semiannualchick:

The COC say they are the only ones going to Heaven. Catholics say their way is the only way, the only true church. OSAS Baptist will tell you that you can be "always forever, never lose it", saved. 

 

Any that doesn't belong to any of those religions is apparently going to Hell. Since all of them can't be right, which one has it right?

I know what the COC, Catholics, & OSAS Baptist will say, I would love to hear the opinion of others.

 

I can just see God judging people. He has a sign on each side of his chair. One says Right (Heaven), the other says Wrong, (Hell) He doesn't say anything, just points to which side a person goes to. The Right & Wrong says it all.

 

Semi, i would suggest that you study and search your heart for whatever beliefs are inside you. everybody believes in something. don't give up till you have the Peace that passes all understanding, and you will know when you have it. God loves you so much, and His heart breaks with you being so confused and unhappy. don't follow the beliefs of anyone else without searching it out for yourself. you are worth way too much to God for Him to just let you slip away...

i hope this helps a little hg<><

Originally Posted by semiannualchick:

The COC say they are the only ones going to Heaven. Catholics say their way is the only way, the only true church. OSAS Baptist will tell you that you can be "always forever, never lose it", saved. 

 

Any that doesn't belong to any of those religions is apparently going to Hell. Since all of them can't be right, which one has it right?

I know what the COC, Catholics, & OSAS Baptist will say, I would love to hear the opinion of others.

 

I can just see God judging people. He has a sign on each side of his chair. One says Right (Heaven), the other says Wrong, (Hell) He doesn't say anything, just points to which side a person goes to. The Right & Wrong says it all.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I know you don't want me saying anything to you so I'll just say this one

thing. God isn't looking for what you do wrong, he just wants to catch you

doing what's right. You're in full control of whether it's heaven or hell for

you. God just lets you know how you did and really, have you done

anything to deserve hell? I didn't think so.

There are No Catholics in Heaven and there aren't any COC, Baptist
or other named Church  affiliated people. It just people that deserve Heaven.

It's not that difficult and certainly not complicated. You might be worrying

too much about it. Steer clear of the potholes until you die. That's all any

of us try to do in the first place.

 

 

 

Hi all,

Chick begins her discussion "Can You Know Where You're Going?" by asking, "The Church Of Christ say they are the only ones going to Heaven.  Catholics say their way is the only way, the only true church.  OSAS (once saved, always save) Baptist will tell you that you can be "always forever, never lose it", saved. Any that don't belong to any of those religions are apparently going to Hell.  Since all of them can't be right, which one has it right?"

Crusty responds correctly, "God isn't going to judge anyone by what church they attend."

And Vic tells her, "I know you don't want me saying anything to you, so I'll just say this one thing.  God isn't looking for what you do wrong, he just wants to catch you doing what's right.  You're in full control of whether it's heaven or hell for you.  God just lets you know how you did and really, have you done anything to deserve hell?  I didn't think so.

There are No Catholics in Heaven and there aren't any Church Of Christ, Baptist, or other named Church affiliated people.  It just people that deserve Heaven.  It's not that difficult and certainly not complicated. You might be worrying too much about it.  Steer clear of the potholes until you die.  That's all any of us try to do in the first place."

On some of Vic's response I agree completely.  Everyone most certainly does choose his/her own personal eternal destination, heaven or hell.  God gave each person the gift of free will.  And, using that free will, each person must individually make a choice:  to follow God, heaven OR to deny God, hell.

When Vic tells her, "There are No Catholics in Heaven, and there aren't any Church Of Christ, Baptist, or other named Church affiliated people." -- I agree with him 100%.  In heaven we will find, besides God and His angels -- only the Old Testament saints, those in the Old Testament who, through faith, believed His promise of a coming Messiah -- and the New Testament saints, i.e., the church, the body of believers worldwide.  One day, the Tribulation saints will be there also.

There are no distinctions, nor denominations -- only saints worshiping and in fellowship with our Lord and Savior.

But, let's discuss Vic's comments, "God just lets you know how you did, and really, have you done anything to deserve hell?" and "It just people that deserve Heaven."

When we speak of deserving hell, we must in the same breath, discuss deserving heaven as he has done.  Yet, we must realize that, because of Adam's disobedience, when sin and death were brought into the creation through this disobedience -- all people have inherited this Adamic Sin Nature.  Thus we all deserve hell.

But, because God loves all His creation and does not want to see anyone perish in hell (2 Peter 3:9), He gives all of us a way to gain eternal life in heaven (John 3:16).

In doing this He has shown both mercy and grace toward us.


Question: "What is the difference between mercy and grace?"

Answer:  Mercy and grace are often confused.  While the terms have similar meanings, grace and mercy are not the same.  To summarize the difference: mercy is God not punishing us as our sins deserve, and grace is God blessing us despite the fact that we do not deserve it.  Mercy is deliverance from judgment.  Grace is extending kindness to the unworthy.   (http://www.gotquestions.org/mercy-grace.html)

 

So, basically, Mercy is us NOT getting what we do deserve, eternal death.  And Grace is us getting what we NO NOT deserve, eternal life.

How do we get this eternal life which God, through His grace, wants to give us?   Ephesians 2:8-9, "For by grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not as a result of works, so that no one may boast."

This tells us that we cannot work our way into heaven.  No amount of works -- unless they are preceded by salvation, gained by grace, through faith -- can get anyone into heaven.  No one has ever been able to answer the age old questions:  "How much works do I have to do to gain heaven?" and "When will I know that I have done enough works to gain heaven?"  Why not?  Because one cannot do enough works to gain heaven.

Yet, one can, by the grace of God, through faith in the finished work of Jesus Christ -- believe and receive this most precious gift -- eternal life in Christ.

How about the Old Testament people, how could they be saved?  Jesus tells us, in John 14:6, "I am the Way, and the Truth, and the Life; NO ONE comes to the Father, but through Me."    And, that NO ONE included the Old Testament people as well -- they could only come to heaven through Jesus Christ.

But, you might say, Jesus Christ was not around for them to believe in during the Old Testament days.  Well, that is not really true; He was there, He has always been there -- for He is preexisting.  In the Old Testament they were told of their coming Messiah, which would be Jesus Christ Incarnate.  If they believed God and looked forward to their Messiah coming -- they were saved.  You can read about this in Hebrews, chapter 11, the Faith Chapter.

So, the Old Testament saints went straight into heaven?  No.  Wait a minute, you said they were saved by faith.  True, but since Jesus Christ had not yet become the Incarnate God, our Savior come to pay our sin debt in full by dying on the cross in our place to offer us eternal life, and resurrecting from the dead to assure our resurrection into immortal life -- the Old Testament believers could not go into heaven yet.

But, they surely would not go into hell; so, where?  They went into Hades/Paradise where they existed happily in the presence of Abraham.  This is often called the Bosom of Abraham.  But, those who did not believe, upon death went into Hades/Torment which was really not a very desirable place to exist.  You can read about this in Luke 16:19-31.

When Jesus Christ was crucified and resurrected, first He led those faithful Old Testament believers out of Hades/Paradise and into heaven (Ephesians 4:8). So, just as we are told in John 14:6, those Old Testament saints went into the presence of the Father, through, or with, Jesus Christ.

Now that the doors of heaven have been thrown open by His death, resurrection, and ascension back into heaven -- all believers, i.e., all saints. immediately upon death go directly into the presence of the the Father, God.  Yet, all non-believers still go into Hades/Torment to await their resurrection to judgment at the Great White Throne of Jesus Christ (Revelation 20:11-15).

So, to answer the question posed by our agnostic Friend, Chick:  YES, we most certainly can know, and choose, where we are going when we die.

The apostle John tells us, in 1 John 5:12, "He who has the Son has the life; he who does not have the Son of God does not have the life."

And, then John further explains why he is telling us this.  1 John 5:13, "These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, so that you may know that you have eternal life."

And, John also wrote in his Gospel of John, "Therefore many other signs Jesus also performed in the presence of the disciples, which are not written in this book; but these have been written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing you may have life in His name" (John 20:30-31).

These Scripture passages, written by the apostle whom Jesus loved, John -- tell us two things:  First, that by believing in Him, we can HAVE life in Him.  And, second, that by believing in Him, we can KNOW that we have eternal life in Christ.  That, my Friend, is "eternal security" or as some call it "Once Saved, Always Saved."

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

 

1 John 5-13 - Bible Inspired By God

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1 John 5-13 - Bible Inspired By God
quote:  Originally Posted by Quaildog:

I’M gonna sit next to veeplee in heaven so I can hear semi hollerin’ at her from below, “makem let me in veeplee”..."best is smokin"!

But, Quail,

 

VP tells us she does not know if she is going to heaven.  She tells us she cannot know.  Yet, Jesus Christ tells us, "He who believes HAS eternal life"  (John 6:47).   Maybe it is not the KNOWING that is holding her back -- but, the BELIEVING what Jesus Christ is telling us.

 

1 John 5:13, "These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, so that you may know that you have eternal life."

 

"Therefore many other signs Jesus also performed in the presence of the disciples, which are not written in this book; but these have been written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing you may have life in His name" (John 20:30-31).

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

quote:  Originally Posted by vplee123:
Right.  So please pray for me that I can someday be made worthy of the promises of Christ.

Hi VP,

 

Simple.  All you have to do is to sincerely invite Him into your heart to be your Lord and Savior (John 3:5, John 3:16, Ephesians 1:13, 4:30, Ephesians 2:8-9, Revelation 3:20).

 

And, when you do that, then you can have faith in your own salvation, for He tells you in John 6:47 "Truly, truly, I say to you, he (or she) who believes has eternal life."  

 

So, sincerely believe and invite Him into your heart (Revelation 3:20) -- and you have a lock on eternal life in Christ.  As I said, simple.

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

1 John 5-13 - Bible Inspired By God

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1 John 5-13 - Bible Inspired By God
Sorry, not that simple. You may think you are "good to go" but I know it is wiser to be humble and to work out my salvation in fear and trembling. Not enough to believe. If that were the case, the Bible would have just been a little pamphlet you could slip under my door. Dangerous theology you are promoting here- you could cause people really take a wrong turn
Originally Posted by INVICTUS:
I know you don't want me saying anything to you so I'll just say this onething. God isn't looking for what you do wrong, he just wants to catch you

doing what's right. You're in full control of whether it's heaven or hell for you. God just lets you know how you did and really, have you done anything to deserve hell? I didn't think so.

There are No Catholics in Heaven and there aren't any COC, Baptist or other named Church  affiliated people. It just people that deserve Heaven.

It's not that difficult and certainly not complicated. You might be worrying too much about it. Steer clear of the potholes until you die. That's all any

of us try to do in the first place.

______

Don't want you saying anything to me? Who gave you that little piece of info? I just would like to see less anger out of someone that claims to be a Christian. If you can get to Heaven with your attitude, I’ll be right behind you. (that’s not meant in an ugly way at all)

 

I am so sick of people that say God isn’t the one that sends me to hell. I suppose He leaves it up to people like you & Bill to send me there? God won’t have to “catch” me doing what's right, it’s my nature to do what’s right so it comes naturally. You thought wrong if you think I haven’t done anything to deserve Hell. According to the message you’ve put out here is that I would have to be Catholic & throw away the Bible I was raised on & get the correct one, (whichever that is).

 

According to the Bible I was raised on, I would have to be living the way God intended a true Christian to live. I’m not a Christian, won’t pretend to be, so that got me a fast ticket to hell right there. (of course, according to ole Billy boys OSAS, I’m a shoo in for heaven)

 

Yes, it is that difficult and most certainly is complicated. If you’ll read the Bible I was raised on it tells you exactly how complicated it is. Yours may say differently but I don’t have a Catholic Bible to read, not that I want to.

 

I’m not worrying, I’m just sick of all those people that talk it but don’t walk it. And I’m supposed to believe they’re going to Heaven while I’m going to Hell.

Yeah, real loving God, ain’t He?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

I’m not worrying, I’m just sick of all those people that talk it but don’t walk it. And I’m supposed to believe they’re going to Heaven while I’m going to Hell.

Yeah, real loving God, ain’t He?

 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I don't see much at all in your response that resembles what I was

talking about.

 

So with that, I'm out.

 

 

Originally Posted by INVICTUS:
You might be worrying too much about it.
______
Originally Posted by semiannualchick:.
I’m not worrying, I’m just sick of all those people that talk it but don’t walk it. And I’m supposed to believe they’re going to Heaven while I’m going to Hell.Yeah, real loving God, ain’t He?

 ~~~~~~~~~~~

Originally Posted by INVICTUS:

I don't see much at all in your response that resembles what I was talking about.

So with that, I'm out.

______

 You said I might be worrying too much about it. I let you know I wasn't, that I'm just sick of the pretenders. That's about as simple as I know to put it.

 

It's not an intellectual versus emotional conflict. It's being called to recognize that we are sinful people that fail all the time. We get up, confess/repent and try again. Just like it takes effort to keep a marriage going, so too is a relationship with God. Am I saved? I have been saved, I am being saved, and I pray that when I leave this world God will count me as His.
Originally Posted by vplee123:
Am I saved? I have been saved, I am being saved, and I pray that when I leave this world God will count me as His.

_________

We both know that Satan's favorite son will jump in with his know it all, smart azz attitude but just ignore him, & don't let him interfere with our conversation.

I was not aware that you don't know if you will go to Heaven when you die. Will you share with me why you feel this way? If you rather discuss it in a PM, that will be fine with me.

 

Well, in a nutshell, because I'm a sinner. I make bad choices and do not put God first all the time. I am not worthy of His promises. Yet I strive each day to be a little better. I will always always fall short (we all will)- the only Perfect person was/is Jesus Christ. He tells us how to live, how to treat people, how to be His light and love in this world. I don't measure up. (Who does?) So I rely on His mercy to know my heart is filled with love for Him, and to forgive my sins- over and over;-) If it were as simple as "believing" ie OSAS , the bible would be a very very short book. Do I know I'm going to Heaven? No. The billgrays of the world will hang their hats on the one verse that says "he who believes in me HAS eternal life". But, I know that belief isn't enough. It's our hearts, our actions, our prayer and our need for His mercy and forgiveness that (God willing) will make us worthy of the promises of Christ. Bill will say "how sad you don't even know if you're going to Heaven". It's not sad- it gives me reason to strive to do better every day;-) and I don't know about you, but I would never dare to be so presumptuous to think I am among those who enter the NARROW gate. So, I believe salvation is an ongoing process- not a one-stop shop. Hope that explains things ;-)
In Revelation 3:5 - unless you are an overcomer, Jesus will blot your name out of the book of life. The book of life contains the names of all who have ever entered the service of God. Jesus bade His disciples, "Rejoice, because your names are written in heaven." Luke 10:20. Paul speaks of his faithful fellow workers, "Whose names are in the book of life." Phil. 4:3. Also notice in Revelation 17:8 that our names are not written in the book of life from the foundation of the world, as many people falsely believe. "The beast that thou sawest was, and is not; and shall ascend out of the bottomless pit, and go into perdition: and they that dwell on the earth shall wonder, whose names were not written in the book of life from the foundation of the world, when they behold the beast that was, and is not, and yet is." Revelation 17:8.
Originally Posted by vplee123:
Well, in a nutshell, because I'm a sinner. I make bad choices and do not put God first all the time. I am not worthy of His promises. Yet I strive each day to be a little better. I will always always fall short (we all will)- the only Perfect person was/is Jesus Christ. He tells us how to live, how to treat people, how to be His light and love in this world. I don't measure up. (Who does?) So I rely on His mercy to know my heart is filled with love for Him, and to forgive my sins- over and over;-) If it were as simple as "believing" ie OSAS , the bible would be a very very short book. Do I know I'm going to Heaven? No. The billgrays of the world will hang their hats on the one verse that says "he who believes in me HAS eternal life". But, I know that belief isn't enough. It's our hearts, our actions, our prayer and our need for His mercy and forgiveness that (God willing) will make us worthy of the promises of Christ. Bill will say "how sad you don't even know if you're going to Heaven". It's not sad- it gives me reason to strive to do better every day;-) and I don't know about you, but I would never dare to be so presumptuous to think I am among those who enter the NARROW gate. So, I believe salvation is an ongoing process- not a one-stop shop. Hope that explains things ;-)

veeplee you might point out to mush noggin that Jesus told one woman to "Go and sin NO more" so it must be possible . I find it fairly easy myself.

Originally Posted by vplee123:
Well, in a nutshell, because I'm a sinner. I make bad choices and do not put God first all the time. I am not worthy of His promises. Yet I strive each day to be a little better. I will always always fall short (we all will)- the only Perfect person was/is Jesus Christ. He tells us how to live, how to treat people, how to be His light and love in this world. I don't measure up. (Who does?) So I rely on His mercy to know my heart is filled with love for Him, and to forgive my sins- over and over;-) If it were as simple as "believing" ie OSAS , the bible would be a very very short book. Do I know I'm going to Heaven? No. The billgrays of the world will hang their hats on the one verse that says "he who believes in me HAS eternal life". But, I know that belief isn't enough. It's our hearts, our actions, our prayer and our need for His mercy and forgiveness that (God willing) will make us worthy of the promises of Christ. Bill will say "how sad you don't even know if you're going to Heaven". It's not sad- it gives me reason to strive to do better every day;-) and I don't know about you, but I would never dare to be so presumptuous to think I am among those who enter the NARROW gate. So, I believe salvation is an ongoing process- not a one-stop shop. Hope that explains things ;-)

__________

Vp, I'm on the same page with you. Although I don't fear, I do ask God's forgiveness every day for anything I did that was not pleasing to him.

 

One thing about OSAS that puzzles me. If a person can change for the better, can they not also change for the worst, even after they've been saved? Turn from God and decide not to follow his ways? If so, how can he still be "saved" and go to Heaven?

 


 

Canade- that's exactly what we have been asking of the OSAS believers. We can all fall from grace. At any time- in doing so, if we don't repent, how in the world can we be "still safe". Take a child who is raised in a Christian home, goes through all the motions, then goes away to college and rejects his Christian upbringing. He had been saved. Is he still? If so, where is the accountability? Puzzling philosophy for sure. Honestly I think it is just a "feel good" philosophy/doctrine that is dangerous and reckless.

"Can You Know Where You’re Going?"

 

Early in my military career, I was taught in land nav course to always trust your compass.  I find that to be as true in life.  Though I’ve strayed a time or two, my Compass has never failed to show me the right way.

 

So, knowing my eventual Destination, yes I can. No problem.

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×