I went with Bama because:
1. they either won or found a way to win every game this year (14) and I think they could do it again
2. while they are only getting credit for beating 2 top 10 teams they actually beat 3 because VaTech was ranked high at the time they were beat and made a very strong run later in the year climbing to #3 or #4.
3.10 teams from Bama's schedule went to bowl game and The Tide beat them all
4. The SEC is the best conference out there right now and the only ones who Alabama didn't beat are Georgia and Vandy.
5. I've been a Bama fan for over 40 years and cannot vote against the Tide ever.
You can run stats and stuff and speculate what could happen and it's fun. But it's not going to generate adult dicussions. Somebody on the Bama side will make a snide remark which will immediately be followed by a "Typical Tide Fan" response. It's already happened.
The Crimson Tide won every game, they won the SEC Championship,they won at Auburn and at Tenn. they won the Heisman (One of their players did) and they won the BCS. Saben didn't win Coach of the Year but that's about it. It was a good year to be a Tide fan, so let us enjoy it. I'm sure Auburn will be back if not next year then the year after. So will Tennessee and I hope they are, because a good team needs good opponents.
For the record: I think Auburn got ripped in '04 also.