quote:Has anyone read Collin's book? I've read excerpts, the parts where he gives reasons for his beliefs. Looking at a frozen waterfall and weeping at its beauty, or the stained glass in a cathedral, etc. isn't good evidence.
He's no doubt a brilliant scientist and it is practically impossible to question his credentials. That's not the problem. The problem is his philosophy.
I agree, a frozen waterfall isn't necessarily good evidence of the existence of a higher power. That wasn't what Collins was saying. It wasn't an instant moment where he suddenly found God, but a moment that came after a long time of questioning and searching that helped things become clear for him.
As for Sam Harris' article, he has every right to his opinion. However, to judge Collin's because of his religious beliefs is no different than for a Christian to condemn someone because of their lack of belief. Dr. Collins has proven himself in the scientific and academic community. The fact that he doesn't agree with Harris on the issue of God has nothing to do with whether or not he is capable of performing his new duties.
Harris' article basically proves this statement from Tim Keller correct.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOusFD9PnsA