Skip to main content

Thou Shalt Find It Impossible to Live Like the Bible Tells You to?



Author A.J. Jacobs spent a year trying to follow the 600+ laws he found proscribed in the Bible, and concluded he's doomed to live in sin.



He didn't want to stone adulterers. But that was part of the deal. That's what A.J. Jacobs was being paid for.

"The Hebrew scriptures prescribe a tremendous amount of capital punishment," Jacobs writes in The Year of Living Biblically (Simon & Schuster, 2007), his account of an experiment in which the lifelong agnostic spent 12 months obeying the Old Testament as literally as possible -- while living in an Upper West Side apartment and working for Esquire.

"Think Saudi Arabia, multiply by Texas, then triple that. It wasn't just for murder. You could also be executed for adultery, blasphemy, breaking the Sabbath, perjury, incest, bestiality, and witchcraft, among others. A rebellious son could be sentenced to death. As could a son who is a persistent drunkard and glutton.

"The most commonly mentioned punishment method in the Hebrew Bible is stoning. So I figure, at the very least, I should try to stone. But how?"

At the time, Jacobs was in month two of his venture, still throbbing with a neophyte's enthusiasm: "I want to smash idols," he surprised himself by musing. Gathering a pocketful of tiny white pebbles in Central Park, he strolled until he met an irascible old man who mocked Jacobs' walking stick. When this man -- having been asked -- declared himself an adulterer, Jacobs lobbed a pebble at his chest. It bounced off.

He had grown up in a resolutely secular Jewish home -- sans bar mitzvah, sans Sabbath candles; he was even named after his still-living father, such an Ashkenazic rarity that an El Al security officer, eyeing the "Jr." on his passport six months into the experiment, doubted that Jacobs was even Jewish at all. "I'm Jewish," he writes, "in the same way that Olive Garden is an Italian restaurant."

All through school, even at a university "where you were more likely to study the semiotics of Wicca rituals than the Judeo-Christian tradition" and where the Bible was viewed "as a fusty, ancient book with the same truth quotient as The Faerie Queene," he'd been taught that the Bible inspired "many of humankind's greatest achievements: the civil rights movement, charitable giving, the abolition of slavery." And also, of course, that "it's been used to justify our worst: war, genocide and the subjugation of others."

http://salsa.democracyinaction.org/dia/track.jsp?v=2&c=...2FLLxpgit8rWW5K%2FmF
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

PBA-

I am not trying to get anything going or start a peeing contest or anything, but is this worrying you?

Does it bother you that some people take the Bible at face value or that someone has found something you can't find, or do you simply not believe a word of it and are trying to educate folks?

I'm serious as a heart attack. I wanna know.
quote:
Originally posted by Rebelsnakes:
Trust in PBA, he is a know it all anti-American.



This statement you made is uncalled for. I fought for my country. I did my time in vietnam.

Then a jerk like you calls people unamerican. If you're a true american as you say you're r.e.d.n.e.c.k. Join up Uncle Sam need you! I know a dude that got his teeth knock out just because he called a guy like me unamerican.So, I would be careful who you call unamerican on the street. In here it don't much matter because no one knows who you are. but who ever you are I am asking you not to lower your self to that standard.
quote:
Originally posted by Kindred:
quote:
Originally posted by Rebelsnakes:
Trust in PBA, he is a know it all anti-American.



Which makes you think anyone on here TRUSTS YOU???? LOL!!!!!!

You don't know anything about any of us yet, your feet ain't even dry enough to make the insults you have made.

Vick said it.



KS, you're a sweetheart! Wink
quote:
Originally posted by MomsyDearest:
PBA-

I am not trying to get anything going or start a peeing contest or anything, but is this worrying you?

Does it bother you that some people take the Bible at face value or that someone has found something you can't find, or do you simply not believe a word of it and are trying to educate folks?

I'm serious as a heart attack. I wanna know.


Well, We do have a few that enjoy judging others like youself. Hey but that is cool.
I wonder if God read what you wrote to me? If so, he said What a b*i*t*c*h*. lol Big Grin

I think you and others may think that I am not a God fearing man. Not So! I love the lord God, he has bless me in soooo many ways. Its the hypocrites that bother me. Cool
Last edited by Jan55
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
Are we sarcastic?

No, an honest question. Some of your post are confusing to me. Some come across as sarcastic, some honest.
If I offended you, it was not my intention.
Frowner

Ask the question the way you would like the question ask to you.

Ok, are you a Christian?
quote:
Originally posted by Taciturn:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
Are we sarcastic?

No, an honest question. Some of your post are confusing to me. Some come across as sarcastic, some honest.
If I offended you, it was not my intention.
Frowner

Ask the question the way you would like the question ask to you.

Ok, are you a Christian?



Are you a Christian? I guess that would depend on what your definition is of a Christian. This is why I am so glad that God is doing the judging and not the church denominations or the so-called hypocrites that claim to be christians. I do accept the Lord Jesus as my Saviour and I do believe in baptism and I believe you must repent of your sins to enter the kingdom of Heaven. And I believe in prayer. Smiler P.S. I know I get a little c*o*c*k*y at times. Wink
quote:
Originally posted by PBA:
quote:
Originally posted by Taciturn:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
Are we sarcastic?

No, an honest question. Some of your post are confusing to me. Some come across as sarcastic, some honest.
If I offended you, it was not my intention.
Frowner

Ask the question the way you would like the question ask to you.

Ok, are you a Christian?



Are you a Christian? I guess that would depend on what your definition is of a Christian. This is why I am so glad that God is doing the judging and not the church denominations or the so-called hypocrites that claim to be christians. I do accept the Lord Jesus as my Saviour and I do believe in baptism and I believe you must repent of your sins to enter the kingdom of Heaven. And I believe in prayer. Smiler P.S. I know I get a little c*o*c*k*y at times. Wink

Hi PBA, I tried the same question a few days ago when you posted the pictures of Jesus. At least you answered Taciturn. I also did not understand where you are coming from, I also was NOT trying to offend. Your religious preference is your own. Its just some post are hard to figure out without knowing why you are posting them. Like the 'fat' people causing a rise in insurance. I just assumed I was on your 'sheet' list. Happy Holidays Big Grin
quote:
Originally posted by _Joy_:
PBA, your answer has changed since you answered me when I asked you that some time back. May I ask what happened? If that's too personal and you don't want to talk about it, I understand. Just don't answer & I won't say another word about it. Smiler



Sweetie, I can't even remember yesterday must less remember what I said then. lol This is the way I have always believed. I have to say, that sometimes I have been confused about so many things and don't understand what is going on with folks today. I have been playing catch up and reading more of the bible to get a better understanding and praying for understanding. I do feel that somebody in this forum cares about me and has done some real praying for me. I can't explain it. I won't even try. Smiler
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
sometimes I have been confused about so many things and don't understand what is going on with folks today.

Hey! Been there, Done that!

I have been playing catch up and reading more of the bible to get a better understanding and praying for understanding.

Well..you're a better person than me. I haven't been doing that. I'm still confused about where I stand with God.

I do feel that somebody in this forum cares about me and has done some real praying for me. I can't explain it. I won't even try. Smiler

No need to explain. Your words said it all.
I really am sorry if I offended you.
quote:
Originally posted by littlemeanmama:
quote:
Originally posted by PBA:
quote:
Originally posted by Taciturn:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
Are we sarcastic?

No, an honest question. Some of your post are confusing to me. Some come across as sarcastic, some honest.
If I offended you, it was not my intention.
Frowner

Ask the question the way you would like the question ask to you.

Ok, are you a Christian?



Are you a Christian? I guess that would depend on what your definition is of a Christian. This is why I am so glad that God is doing the judging and not the church denominations or the so-called hypocrites that claim to be christians. I do accept the Lord Jesus as my Saviour and I do believe in baptism and I believe you must repent of your sins to enter the kingdom of Heaven. And I believe in prayer. Smiler P.S. I know I get a little c*o*c*k*y at times. Wink

Hi PBA, I tried the same question a few days ago when you posted the pictures of Jesus. At least you answered Taciturn. I also did not understand where you are coming from, I also was NOT trying to offend. Your religious preference is your own. Its just some post are hard to figure out without knowing why you are posting them. Like the 'fat' people causing a rise in insurance. I just assumed I was on your 'sheet' list. Happy Holidays Big Grin




Hi PBA, I tried the same question a few days ago when you posted the pictures of Jesus. At least you answered Taciturn. I also did not understand where you are coming from, I also was NOT trying to offend. Your religious preference is your own. Its just some post are hard to figure out without knowing why you are posting them. Like the 'fat' people causing a rise in insurance. I just assumed I was on your 'sheet' list. Happy Holidays

Love my cats


I understand what you mean now,I try to get a message across by using pictures, remarks. But never thought about how someone might take it wrong. You have open my eyes and I do thank you for taking the time to do that. It would be a big help to me if you or anyone who is not sure how I mean what I am saying or just do not understand the post please ask me. That way we can understand more which way we really are thinking and why.I have done the same by posting a reply before reading the post as to what it said.I went by the title instead.The title can fool you at times.lol. Have a great weekend!'fat' people causing a rise in insurance
Its true that heavey people as well as smokers paid more. Bigger folks and smokers are not causing everyone insurance to rise. It is true you will pay more for insurance if you're heavy or a smoker and this is also true for life insurance. I was not trying to be ugly,I guess I just worded it wrong. Cool
Last edited by Jan55
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
I guess that would depend on what your definition is of a Christian. This is why I am so glad that God is doing the judging and not the church denominations or the so-called hypocrites that claim to be christians.

I couldn't have put it any better!

I do accept the Lord Jesus as my Saviour and I do believe in baptism and I believe you must repent of your sins to enter the kingdom of Heaven. And I believe in prayer. Smiler

That's great! Not as easy for me but I'm happy for you. Wink
quote:
Originally posted by Taciturn:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by PBA:
I guess that would depend on what your definition is of a Christian. This is why I am so glad that God is doing the judging and not the church denominations or the so-called hypocrites that claim to be christians.

I couldn't have put it any better!

I do accept the Lord Jesus as my Saviour and I do believe in baptism and I believe you must repent of your sins to enter the kingdom of Heaven. And I believe in prayer. Smiler

That's great! Not as easy for me but I'm happy for you. Wink



Thank you very much! Smiler
impossible to live like the Bible tells me to?..by my own power,yes, impossible.
but '*WITH GOD* all things are possible'..

so, i CAN live like the Bible tells me to, but only thru Jesus' blood, which covered my sins as He died for me..
________________________________________________

[QUOTE]I fought for my country. I did my time in vietnam.

ANYONE who fought for our country, especially in vietnam, while i was here growing up, is a HERO in my book..thank you, PBA.
Last edited by thehippiegirl is gone.
quote:
Originally posted by PBA:
quote:
Originally posted by MomsyDearest:
PBA-

I am not trying to get anything going or start a peeing contest or anything, but is this worrying you?

Does it bother you that some people take the Bible at face value or that someone has found something you can't find, or do you simply not believe a word of it and are trying to educate folks?

I'm serious as a heart attack. I wanna know.


Well, We do have a few that enjoy judging others like youself. Hey but that is cool.
I wonder if God read what you wrote to me? If so, he said What a b*i*t*c*h*. lol Big Grin

I think you and others may think that I am not a God fearing man. Not So! I love the lord God, he has bless me in soooo many ways. Its the hypocrites that bother me. Cool


PBA-
I'm sorry. Reading back over my post--my wording ...it does sound smart-mouthed. I didn't intend for it to.

I wondered if you were wondering about what the Bible said, or if you were trying to refute it... I clearly misunderstood.

Please check your PMs.
Last edited by MomsyDearest
quote:
Originally posted by PBA:
quote:
Originally posted by _Joy_:
PBA, your answer has changed since you answered me when I asked you that some time back. May I ask what happened? If that's too personal and you don't want to talk about it, I understand. Just don't answer & I won't say another word about it. Smiler



Sweetie, I can't even remember yesterday must less remember what I said then. lol This is the way I have always believed. I have to say, that sometimes I have been confused about so many things and don't understand what is going on with folks today. I have been playing catch up and reading more of the bible to get a better understanding and praying for understanding. I do feel that somebody in this forum cares about me and has done some real praying for me. I can't explain it. I won't even try. Smiler


PBA, you must have turkey and dressing once each week or those praying must remember to do so. You just keep getting nicer and nicer. Smiler Hmmm....could that be because everyone else has been nicer? Whatever it is, I like it! Thanks for sharing that with us. All of us have had our mouths get us in trouble from time to time. Apparently, turkey has the opposite effect on me...haha. So, please pray that God will shut my mouth. Big Grin
I understand what you mean now,I try to get a message across by using pictures, remarks. But never thought about how someone might take it wrong. You have open my eyes and I do thank you for taking the time to do that. It would be a big help to me if you or anyone who is not sure how I mean what I am saying or just do not understand the post please ask me. That way we can understand more which way we really are thinking and why.I have done the same by posting a reply before reading the post as to what it said.I went by the title instead.The title can fool you at times.lol. Have a great weekend!'fat' people causing a rise in insurance
Its true that heavey people as well as smokers paid more. Bigger folks and smokers are not causing everyone insurance to rise. It is true you will pay more for insurance if you're heavy or a smoker and this is also true for life insurance. I was not trying to be ugly,I guess I just worded it wrong. Cool[/QUOTE]

Apology accepted and have a very Merry Christmas any way you want to. Big Grin

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×