Skip to main content

Hi to my Forum Friends,

The dialogue below began in the discussion I began titled, "Willie, Millie, And The Rapture!" -- but, because I want to share this with everyone, I have decided to break it out and start a new discussion.

In that previous discussion, my Friend, Jan, told me, '"Ok lets see if I qualify to be "enlightened" on the subject of adding to the KJV of the bible. I was only born once. I am not a Christian believer. I am not a serial killer. (but wouldn't your religion expect you to teach even those that are the worst kind of sinners?)

I spent 17 horrible years in organized religion. Even though you didn't ask I will tell you it was of the COC flavor.

Now, can you tell me the big secret of where you got THIS fairy tale? I know it did not come from your favorite fairy tale book because I have read it and its not there."


Since the discussion was "Willie, Millie, And The Rapture!" -- I presume you are asking about the Rapture. But, first let me address some of your other issues. You tell us that you attended a Church of Christ for seventeen years; but, never became a Christian believer, never sought a saving relationship with Jesus Christ.

Believe it or not, I do understand. While you spent seventeen unpleasant years because of your reaction to this church; I spent almost forty years running from God -- because of what happened to me in a similar church in Sheffield. When I was about twelve, a traveling Revival Preacher laid a heavy trip on me -- and I ran from God until I was fifty.

But, praise God, when I was fifty, I met a true man of God, a pastor who exuded the love of God, not the wrath of God -- and who was not trying to accumulate numbers to support a Revival score. This man was Pastor Sam Lacanienta -- and, I, and many others who have been saved through his ministry -- thank God for him.

Let's stop for a moment and respond to the rash of giggling and twittering I know will be coming from our Friends in the cheap seats. This is for Deep and our other atheist/secularist Friends -- for the handful of those who wear a Christian hat; but, obviously have not found one that fit yet -- and for all of our non-believing Friends who literally wet their pants every time someone tells them, "Jesus loves you!"

The first thing, when they can stop their giggling and twittering, that they will write is: "Mr. Pot, meet Mr. Kettle!" -- implying that I write one thing and live another.

Now that we are past that anticipated intelligent reply -- let me respond by saying, "Just because we Christian believers tell you that you must be born again to be save -- just because we tell you that you have to choose between an eternity in heaven and an eternity in hell -- just because we tell you that, by grace, through faith in Jesus Christ; plus NOTHING else, you are saved -- you say we are spewing 'wrath' upon you." No, my Friends, we are, out of Christian love, sincerely trying to point you toward the path of eternal happiness and joy.

Now, Jan, with that out of the way; let's continue with answering your questions regarding the Rapture.

You tell me that I have been '"adding to the KJV of the bible." Even though I normally use the NASB in my personal Bible studies and in my writings; I will use the King James Bible in this discussion so that we are speaking "apples and apples." Jan, I would not try to add to God's Written Word; for I am not worthy to do this. I can only share what I find in His Written Word, the Bible.

Then, you tell me, '"Now can you tell me the big secret of where you got THIS fairy tale? I know it did not come from your favorite fairy tale book because I have read it and its not there."

First, for the sake of our readers, you are referring to the Rapture. And, you tell us that you have read this "fairy tale book." It would seem that we have been reading different books -- for the Bible is far from being a "fairy tale book." But, possibly, that is why you could never find anything it it -- you had your eyes closed while reading. Here I am speaking, not of your physical eyes -- but, of your spiritual eyes.

Once again, like you, before I was a Christian believer, I tried many times to read the Bible and could not make any sense of it at all. For many years, I traveled on business. I lived a big part of those years in hotel rooms; so, I know what loneliness is and how depressing it can be to a person.

In this loneliness and depression, I often took the Gideon's Bible out of the bedside night stand drawer -- and tried to read it. So many times I had heard of people who had found peace and comfort reading this book. Yet, all I found was frustration and confusion. Why? Because my spiritual eyes were closed. I knew that God and Jesus Christ were in there -- I just did not know how to find them.

My Friend, possibly you have the same "spiritual eyes blindness" problem I had all those years. The way around this is to sincerely pray and ask God to open your eyes, your spiritual eyes.

Now, back to your question of the Rapture. Is it in the King James Bible? Yes!

In 1 Thessalonians 4:17 (kjv), we read, "Then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord."

The phrase "shall be caught up" in Greek is "harpazo" and in Strong's Concordance we are told this means: (1) to seize, carry off by force, (2) to seize on, claim for one's self eagerly, (3) to snatch out or away.

The Bible was originally written in three languages: Hebrew (most of the OT), Aramaic (part of the OT), and Greek (the NT). In 382 A.D., Pope Damasus I commissioned Jerome of Stridon, northern Croatia, to translate the Bible into Latin.

The Latin Vulgate was translated from the original languages into Latin by Jerome in the time period 382 - 405 A.D. For over a millennium, it was the preferred translation for the church. Jerome translated into Latin, the Old Testament from the Hebrew and Aramaic, and the New Testament from Greek. The Latin Vulgate became the Bible of the Western Church until the Protestant Reformation in the 1500s.

In the Latin Vulgate, the Greek word harpazo ("shall be caught up" in English) was translated rapiemur. And, the Latin word rapiemur has been transliterated into the English word "rapture."

So, Jan, yes -- the word "rapture" is indeed found in the Bible; but, one has to look back to the Latin Vulgate to find its word origin.

Yet, in the Bible we do see other instances of a "rapture" occurring.

In 2 Kings 2:11 (kjv), Elijah and Elisha are walking and talking when we read that Elijah was taken up, "And it came to pass, as they still went on, and talked, that, behold, there appeared a chariot of fire, and horses of fire, and parted them both asunder; and Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven."

In this Scripture passage, Elijah did not physically die -- yet, he was taken up into Paradise, i.e., heaven. This can only be seen as a "rapture."

In 2 Corinthians 12:2-4 (kjv), the apostle Paul tells of his own "rapture like" experience, "I knew a man in Christ above fourteen years ago, (whether in the body, I cannot tell; or whether out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth), such an one caught up to the third heaven. And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth). How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter."

In Revelation 4:1 (kjv), the apostle John is shown a prophetic timeline in a "rapture like" experience, "After this I looked, and, behold, a door was opened in heaven: and the first voice which I heard was as it were of a trumpet talking with me; which said, Come up hither, and I will shew thee things which must be hereafter."

But, the most famous "rapture" event is described in Acts 1:9-11, "And when He (Jesus Christ) had spoken these things, while they beheld, He was taken up; and a cloud received Him out of their sight. And while they looked stedfastly toward heaven as He went up, behold, two men stood by them in white apparel (angels); which also said, Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing up into heaven? This same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven."

That, my Friend, was the Rapture of Jesus Christ. He was ALIVE; then, He was taken up into heaven. He did not die again; He was raptured into heaven.

Yet, these two angels tell His disciples, in Acts 1:11, "This same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven."

In other words, Jesus Christ will come again -- to Rapture His church from this world. He went up, i.e., "a cloud received Him out of their sight" -- and He shall come again, in the clouds, to gather, rapture, His church (1 Thessalonians 4:17).

Yet, there is one more amazing Rapture event which will occur after our Rapture.

In Revelation 11:7-12 (kjv), we read of the Two Witnesses sent by God to preach His Word to those lost in worldly sin during the Tribulation, "And when they shall have finished their testimony, the beast that ascendeth out of the bottomless pit (the Antichrist possessed by Satan) shall make war against them, and shall overcome them, and kill them.

And their dead bodies shall lie in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified. And they of the people and kindreds and tongues and nations shall see their dead bodies three days and an half, and shall not suffer their dead bodies to be put in graves. And they that dwell upon the earth shall rejoice over them, and make merry, and shall send gifts one to another; because these two prophets tormented them that dwelt on the earth.

And after three days and an half the Spirit of life from God entered into them, and they stood upon their feet; and great fear fell upon them which saw them. And they heard a great voice from heaven saying unto them, Come up hither. And they ascended up to heaven in a cloud; and their enemies beheld them."


Do you notice the similarity through all these passages? Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven; Paul was caught up into paradise; John was told, "Come up hither." Jesus was taken up; and a cloud received Him out of their sight. The angels tells His disciples that Jesus "shall so come in like manner."

In other words, He went up "in the clouds" -- He shall return "in the clouds" to redeem His church, His body of believers (1 Thessalonians 4:17). And, the Two Witnesses of the Tribulation "ascended up to heaven in a cloud."

Yes, my Friend, the Rapture is taught in the Bible -- and the Rapture is shown in the Bible. It is in both the Old Testament and in the New Testament. The Rapture is taught in regular Scripture -- and it is taught in prophecy. With all of these examples; it is difficult to deny that Jesus Christ will return to take up, snatch out, rapture, His church before the Tribulation begins (Revelation 3:10,
1 Thessalonians 5:9).

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The Rapture is elluded to in many ways. Is it literal? Symbolic? Pre-Mid-Post Rapture theories, and debates about what will happen in end times.
Let's face it- NOBODY KNOWS! Those who state that they "KNOW" unequivocably are lying. Or brainwashed. Or pushing their own Fundamentalist agendas. It is impossible to interpret Revelations scripture with any certainty.
We go on Faith alone- that God will find us in good standing, and in His friendship when He comes in glory. Most Christians agree that Christ will come again. But how, when and the details of this are just going to have to be a surprise.
I would suggest reading "The Rapture Trap". It is a great book, in response to the "Left Behind" Series.
I say it's time to stop worrying about what "MIGHT" happen, and how/when/etc, and start worrying about how we use this short life we are given. How we treat one another, and how we live out God's love every day.
Everything else is speculation, and secondary to the real reason we are here.
Bill you are going to have to get that Prozac Bottle filled, nowhere does it say anything about the Rapture, why do you work so hard to try to make it say things that it don't say? say you are 73? very soon you will have all your questions answered, you don't have to go back and do all that research, the Bible is written at the 7th and 8th Grade level and the average word is 5 letters long, why do you have to go back to somebody that knows no more than the rest of us?
Hi VP,

Not a problem. You are free to live your "maybe I'm saved -- maybe I'm not" life; you are free to depend upon long dead mortals to save you, or whatever security you gather from them.

But, for me, I will stick to the Bible, what it teaches me -- and KNOW that I have eternal life in Jesus Christ.

But, if anyone has noticed; all you do is keep yelling, "That is not right!" Yet, you NEVER tell us what you believe the Bible is telling us about salvation and the End Times.

To you, everything I write is wrong -- but, you do not offer any truth. All you can offer is "maybe this is true; maybe that is true" -- but, you offer us nothing based upon Scripture.

Now, when I ask you to offer us something based upon Scripture -- I mean what YOU have learned from Scripture -- not what some priest has TOLD YOU Scripture says. How about YOU get into Scripture and give us your Scriptural interpretation of the End Times. Or, do you believe the world we live in will never end?

VP, offer us something beside just negative thoughts. Put some meat on your bones of disagreement!

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
quote:
Originally posted by prince albert:
Bill you are going to have to get that Prozac Bottle filled, nowhere does it say anything about the Rapture, why do you work so hard to try to make it say things that it don't say? say you are 73? very soon you will have all your questions answered, you don't have to go back and do all that research, the Bible is written at the 7th and 8th Grade level and the average word is 5 letters long, why do you have to go back to somebody that knows no more than the rest of us?

Hi Albert,

I have shown you Scripturally why I know there will be a Rapture. Show us Scripturally why you think this will not happen.

And, while you are at it -- please interpret 1 Thessalonians 4:17 for us.

You might also give us, Scripturally, your understanding of End Time Eschatology.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
Sorry Bill.

Nothing negative about it.
Au contraire, what I said is you should stop trying to prophezise what will happen in End Times, and start living in the present.
You don't have all the answers. And yea, I disagree with you because you speak as though you "KNOW" all the answers. You don't.
I have given you plenty of scripture in past discussions, to contradict your "once saved always saved" zero accountability view. Usually you ignore it. That's fine! But you better be careful- if you are confident in your salvation, you just might sin- and fall from Christ's friendship. What if one of your Raptures occurs then??
Why was this nonsense ever taught by the Church Fathers, who, instead, denounced the entire "1000 Year Reign of Christ on earth" as "Jewish superstition" and that such could not be safely taught in public?
Why is this not in the Creeds?
Why must one parse out verses that might or might not allude to a "rapture" of the "Night of the Living with "Transporter Beam" to Heaven"?
Why is the Holy Bible so relatively unclear about the end of the world yet has so much to teach us about living according to the Gospel and example of Our Lord?

Spare us your "Baptiscostal" or whatever sect you claim's assessment on the "End Times", please! Most of us care about today and tomorrow and not about what might happen. It is heresy to teach this as binding on any man.

All you seem to care about is the gays, Republican politics, and lies and misrepresentations.

Frightened by a preacher! Now that is novel: hardly. Your choices seem rooted in alleged gay wandering eyes and scary preachers leading to a life of Semi-Catholicism (which I personally doubt) and crystal balls. This just too silly to consider as being held by any true Christian who never once mentions the poor or compassion.

It's not too late, even with the brain arteries continuing to harden.
Last edited by Aude Sapere
quote:
Originally posted by vplee123:
Sorry Bill. Nothing negative about it.
Au contraire, what I said is you should stop trying to prophezise what will happen in End Times, and start living in the present.
You don't have all the answers. And yea, I disagree with you because you speak as though you "KNOW" all the answers. You don't.
I have given you plenty of scripture in past discussions, to contradict your "once saved always saved" zero accountability view. Usually you ignore it. That's fine! But you better be careful- if you are confident in your salvation, you just might sin- and fall from Christ's friendship. What if one of your Raptures occurs then??

Hi VP,

All that aside -- now, tell us, as best you can -- your views of the End Times. Will there be an End Times and, if so, what will happen and when?

You say I am wrong in my interpretation of Biblical End Times events. Then, please, tell us your Biblical End Time events views.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 0_-_CROSS-BIBLE_SAID-IT-1c
What do I believe?

God will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and His Kingdom will have no end.

Period. End of it. We will not know the time, nor will there be signs pointing to the "end time".

There are so many different "camps" relating to the Rapture: pretrib, mid, post tribulation, etc.
Personally, I will just stick with the knowledge that He will come again in glory.I won't pretend to understand God's ways in this.But I will say, that I don't believe God will look kindly on those who claim to be righteous, and deserving of a "free pass" to Heaven. I don't believe God will look kindly on those who fail to show love to others based on their religious convictions, sexuality, illness, social class, race.
He will look for those who have lived by Christ's example of humility, charity and love.
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
quote:
Originally posted by prince albert:
Bill you are going to have to get that Prozac Bottle filled, nowhere does it say anything about the Rapture, why do you work so hard to try to make it say things that it don't say? say you are 73? very soon you will have all your questions answered, you don't have to go back and do all that research, the Bible is written at the 7th and 8th Grade level and the average word is 5 letters long, why do you have to go back to somebody that knows no more than the rest of us?

Hi Albert,

I have shown you Scripturally why I know there will be a Rapture. Show us Scripturally why you think this will not happen.

And, while you are at it -- please interpret 1 Thessalonians 4:17 for us.

You might also give us, Scripturally, your understanding of End Time Eschatology.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill


1Thess 4:16 For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven, with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first;
1Thess 4:17 then we that are alive, that are left, shall together with them be caught up in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and shall ever be with the Lord. What is so hard to understand about them two verses bill? I believe a 7th grader could tell you what they mean. but you want to use your (didn't I read where you said that you had a PhD?)if so that is the Problem, you see the Bible was wrote where the every day Person can understand it. and you have moved in the group where the lord said Rom 1:22 Professing themselves to be wise, they became as fools,

and Peter tells us in 2Pet 3:10 But the day of the Lord will come as a thief; in the which the heavens shall pass away with a great noise, and the elements shall be dissolved with fervent heat, and the earth and the works that are therein shall be burned up. where are they going to set Davids Throne up for Christ to reign a Thousand years since the Earth will be burned up?

the End time Eschatology is explained in 1st Thessolonians Chapter 4 verses 16&17 as good as any way I know to describe it.
Hi Albert,

You have quoted 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17 and tell me I am wrong in my understanding of this passage. Let's take a look:

1 Thessalonians 4:16-18, "For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we shall always be with the Lord. Therefore comfort one another with these words."

"For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven" -- that is what I have said; that He is coming back for His church.

"the dead in Christ will rise first" -- this, also, is what I have said -- that those who have died in Christ will be raised first.

"Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air" -- then, those believers who are still alive will be "caught up" -- harpazo -- "raptured" to meet with those saints who had just been taken up before us. And, together we will all meet the Lord in the clouds where He waits to give us our immortal, glorified bodies -- that we may be like Him -- immortal beings.

"and so we shall always be with the Lord" -- and we will be with Him eternally -- that is "eternal security."

"Therefore comfort one another with these words" -- yes, all believers should find comfort in His assurance of the coming Rapture and our eternal life with Him. And, non-believers should take warning that, if they do not repent, i.e., turn from the world and turn to follow Him, and believe -- they will miss out on this fantastic promise.

Albert, I am not sure what you say I am missing in this Scripture passage. However, I am eager to learn more; so, please tell me your interpretation of this passage.

It is okay to tell me I am wrong -- but, only if you can show me where I am wrong and what is the right interpretation. To just tell me that a seventh grader should see the truth is not sufficient. Please explain your understanding of 1 Thessalonians 4:16-18.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
Bill I get the same meaning you do from 1st Thessolonians 16&17 it is the word "Rapture" that I have trouble with, Evidently it comes from that Book ya'll have to have to go along with the Bible to make your Doctrine say the things you want it to say, you see we dont have a little Book to help us along, we only need the Bible, and we don't have a Missionary Society to keep us straight and we don't have Preachers telling us that we are behind on our Love offering, because we Pay them well and we don't have Love offerings, we don't Tithe because it says to give as you have been prospered, we only Pay our Preacher $500.00 a week because he has a regular Job that he works, I go to a rural Church and there is only 32 people goes there counting children.

if we offered Entertainment and have Fish Suppers we could fill the Building, but they would be coming to be Entertained and Fed like the big churches with the Kitchens and Baseball Fields, so you see at least we are only going to worship God and Judgement Day we will only have to answer for our personal lives, not the way we handled the word of God.
quote:
Originally posted by prince albert:
Bill, I get the same meaning you do from 1st Thessolonians 16&17. It is the word "Rapture" that I have trouble with. Evidently it comes from that Book ya'll have to have to go along with the Bible to make your Doctrine say the things you want it to say. You see we don't have a little Book to help us along, we only need the Bible.

Hi Albert,

I am not sure what book you mean. The only book I need is the Bible. I will often refer to commentaries just to get a flavor of what Bible scholars and theologians think about a particular Scripture verse or passage. But, ultimately, my interpretation comes from my own reading and study of the Bible.

In my previous post, I explained how we find the word Rapture. It is in the Bible -- in 1 Thessalonians 4:16-18, "For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we shall always be with the Lord. Therefore comfort one another with these words."

The phrase "caught up" in Greek is "harpazo." In the Bible you study in your church, the New Testament was all written in Greek. So, in your Bible that phrase "caught up" is the Greek word "harpazo."

I will presume that, to this point, we are still in agreement.

In 382 A.D. Jerome was commissioned to translate the Bible -- the Hebrew and Aramaic of the Old Testament and the Greek of the New Testament -- to Latin. This produced the Latin Vulgate. In Latin the Greek word "harpazo" is translated into the Latin word "rapiemur." And, the Latin word "rapiemur" has been transliterated into the English word "rapture."

Just as we have taken the Hebrew representation of the name of God, YHWH, and transliterated this into the English word Yahweh -- we have done the same with "rapiemur" being transliterated, using the English alphabet sounds, and deriving the English word "rapture."

So, Albert, yes, both the word Rapture and the teaching of it is your Bible. However, if you choose to deny there will be a Rapture, this will not affect your salvation. We will both know the truth on the way up.

Albert, I am not sure if your church teaches Amillennialism, i.e., that there will be no Rapture, no Tribulation, and no Millennial Kingdom -- or if you teach PostMillennialism, believing there will be a Tribulation and a Millennial Kingdom; but, Jesus Christ will not be here, He will be in heaven acting as an absentee landlord.

However, the Bible clearly teaches a PreTribulation Rapture of the church -- and a PreMillennial Second Coming of Jesus Christ.

How you believe will not affect your salvation; but, boy are you going to be surprised when He does come in the clouds and we are "caught up" (harpazo, rapiemur, raptured) to meet Him in the clouds (together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. 1 Thessalonians 4:17).

Personally, I do not see how anyone can deny the Rapture, the Tribulation, or the Millennial Kingdom -- when these are so clearly taught in the Bible.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
quote:
Originally posted by prince albert:
Bill I get the same meaning you do from 1st Thessolonians 16&17 it is the word "Rapture" that I have trouble with, Evidently it comes from that Book ya'll have to have to go along with the Bible to make your Doctrine say the things you want it to say, you see we dont have a little Book to help us along, we only need the Bible, and we don't have a Missionary Society to keep us straight and we don't have Preachers telling us that we are behind on our Love offering, because we Pay them well and we don't have Love offerings, we don't Tithe because it says to give as you have been prospered, we only Pay our Preacher $500.00 a week because he has a regular Job that he works, I go to a rural Church and there is only 32 people goes there counting children.

if we offered Entertainment and have Fish Suppers we could fill the Building, but they would be coming to be Entertained and Fed like the big churches with the Kitchens and Baseball Fields, so you see at least we are only going to worship God and Judgement Day we will only have to answer for our personal lives, not the way we handled the word of God.



Click for article on the WORD Rapture

Rather than say essentially the same thing and type it all the above link should sufficiently address where some Christians come up with the word "Rapture" which, as you correctly stated is not literally in the Scriptures. Many Christians don't accept or believe in a Rapture either many others (including myself) do. The important thing is each person be confident in their interpretation and know the basis for their beliefs and faith.

vplee123, I understand your concern or advice in living in the present or concerning yourself with what's going on now and why worry or concern yourself with "the Rapture". I, like Bill, do believe that the scriptures prophecy and tell of a "Catching up" of God's "saints' or saved Christians however Bill and I disagree about the exact timing of that Rapture. It is my belief that the Rapture (or Catching up) of the Saints occurs immediately before God's Wrath is released (in Revelation chapter 8).

Without rehashing all that Bill and I have (at best) debated about I will just say that the reason for a Christian (one at least that believes in a Catching away/Rapture) is so that "The Church" or Christians will be prepared to endure an extreme hardship that will precede this catching away. See that's one area Bill and I disagree on, the Timing. I believe that Christians and the Church (those alive at the next coming of Christ) will endure extreme hardships that have never been seen before

it comes from the following

Matthew 24:6-22 (CEV)
6 You will soon hear about wars and threats of wars, but don't be afraid. These things will have to happen first, but that isn't the end. 7 Nations and kingdoms will go to war against each other. People will starve to death, and in some places there will be earthquakes. 8 But this is just the beginning of troubles. 9 You will be arrested, punished, and even killed. Because of me, you will be hated by people of all nations. 10 Many will give up and will betray and hate each other. 11 Many false prophets will come and fool a lot of people. 12 Evil will spread and cause many people to stop loving others. 13 But if you keep on being faithful right to the end, you will be saved. 14 When the good news about the kingdom has been preached all over the world and told to all nations, the end will come. 15 Someday you will see that "Horrible Thing" in the holy place, just as the prophet Daniel said. Everyone who reads this must try to understand! 16 If you are living in Judea at that time, run to the mountains. 17 If you are on the roof of your house, don't go inside to get anything. 18 If you are out in the field, don't go back for your coat. 19 It will be a terrible time for women who are expecting babies or nursing young children. 20 And pray that you won't have to escape in winter or on a Sabbath. 21 This will be the worst time of suffering since the beginning of the world, and nothing this terrible will ever happen again. 22 If God doesn't make the time shorter, no one will be left alive. But because of God's chosen ones, he will make the time shorter.

Essentially the reason, I believe, it is to be preached, taught, and studied, is so that those that are alive and living in those end days, will recognize it as that and be prepared, ahead of time, for the suffering they will have to endure.

Bill, on the other hand, doesn't believe Christians will endure this suffering as taught in Matthew 24 and will be "Caught away" before any of Revelation Chapter 6 or what I posted in Matthew occurs. Again Bill and I have had intense disagreement about this timing but yet we both do believe in a Catching away of the Church. Don't know if any of this helps but thought I would insert it.
Revelation 3:10, "Because you have kept the word of My perseverance, I also will keep you from the hour of testing, that hour which is about to come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth."

1 Thessalonians 5:9, "For God has not destined us for wrath, but for obtaining salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ."

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 0_-_CROSS-BIBLE_SAID-IT-1c
I have a question, stemming from something VP said.

If you live your life by God's laws and Christs words, are saved, and love they neighbor, all that jazz,

does the idea of a rapture make any difference, one way or the other?

i can't see that it does. if you are in a state of grace, you'll be caught up if it happens. if you aren't, you won't be whether it happens or not. if you are in a state of grace and it doesn't happen, you're no worse off and will end up in heaven the normal way.

I can't see how it makes any difference whether it's real or just inventive imagination and wishful thinking.

In short simple words, and with out throwing bible verses at me, some one explain why it's relevent?

i'm not being a smartass here.. i just really honestly don't understand how it's significant, if you live by The Rules.
Or even if you don't, for that matter.
Right. It doesn't matter. Like I said in an earlier post, we believe that Christ will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead,and His Kingdom will have no end.

That's all there is to it.

What gets me all riled up, is when the holier-than-thou think they are guaranteed to be "poofed" up magically into the air, like a scene out of a cheesy movie.
I think much of end times prophesizing is a waste of time. It's just when people get all rapture-y, and "i'm not gonna have to suffer cause I'm saved" kind of self-righteousness.

I think this line of thinking detracts from what we are called to be: Humble, acknowledging that we will ALWAYS be sinful,and always fall short.
We do need to trust in God's mercy, but we should always be humble. That is what I find to be lacking in the 'bible thumping'
rapture-esque school of thoughts...
They think they know everything. and it does drive me somewhat crazy. The bottom line, is nobody knows! And no, I don't really care,I always try to keep a contrite heart, and don't take God's forgiveness as a onestop shop= Icontinually ask for it. Cuz I sin ALL THE TIME!
And like i've said a kazillion times, it's not how many scripture verses we can recite ver batim, but how we treat our fellow peeps.
SmilerVeep.
quote:
Originally posted by vplee123:
Right. It doesn't matter. Like I said in an earlier post, we believe that Christ will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead,and His Kingdom will have no end.

Hi VP,

But, when will He come in glory -- and how?

Will He come PreMillennial, PostMillennial, Amillennial?

When and where will His kingdom be established?

When will He judge the living and the dead?

These are all questions from statements you have made or alluded to; so, from the Bible how will you answer them.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
quote:
Originally posted by thenagel:
I have a question, stemming from something VP said.

If you live your life by God's laws and Christs words, are saved, and love they neighbor, all that jazz, does the idea of a rapture make any difference, one way or the other?

Hi Nagel,

How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation. However, it most certainly has an affect upon your peace of mind and your eternal security.

If you believe that you will have to suffer horrible wraths, the same as those who deny God, for seven years -- would you have any peace of mind? No, you would be too busy worrying about the terrible wraths you will have to suffer.

And, why? Jesus Christ tells us that believers will NOT suffer the wraths (Revelation 3:10, 1 Thessalonians 5:9). Do you NOT believe the promises of Jesus Christ? Do you believe He would lie to you? Of course He will not. So, why get yourself all in a dither worrying about wraths which you will not suffer?

This is the importance of our Rapture view. However, if you are a sadomasochist who enjoys and looks forward to wrath and pain -- then, I guess you will not want the Rapture to happen.

But, for me and my loved ones -- I praise God for His promises -- and look forward to being snatched up into the clouds to meet my Lord and Savior.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
quote:
But, when will He come in glory -- and how?

Will He come PreMillennial, PostMillennial, Amillennial?

When and where will His kingdom be established?

When will He judge the living and the dead?

These are all questions from statements you have made or alluded to; so, from the Bible how will you answer them.


Bill- I don't know.
Simple as that. Nobody does. It's so presumptuous and arrogant to presume to know how/when/etc Jesus will make His return.
My goodness. Does it matter? No.
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
quote:
Originally posted by thenagel:
I have a question, stemming from something VP said.

If you live your life by God's laws and Christs words, are saved, and love they neighbor, all that jazz, does the idea of a rapture make any difference, one way or the other?

Hi Nagel,

How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation.


OK. that's what i was wondering. thanks, Bill.
quote:
Originally posted by thenagel:
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
Hi Nagel, How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation.

OK. that's what i was wondering. thanks, Bill.

Hi Nagel,

HOW'S THE TUNNEL VISION?

Actually written by Bill Gray:

How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation. However, it most certainly has an affect upon your peace of mind and your eternal security.

If you believe that you will have to suffer horrible wraths, the same as those who deny God, for seven years -- would you have any peace of mind? No, you would be too busy worrying about the terrible wraths you will have to suffer.

Y'all come back now, ya heah?

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Charlie-Brown_Snoopy-2_CLOUDS_IN-WITH
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
quote:
Originally posted by thenagel:
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
Hi Nagel, How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation.

OK. that's what i was wondering. thanks, Bill.

Hi Nagel,

HOW'S THE TUNNEL VISION?

Actually written by Bill Gray:

How you view the Rapture has no affect upon your salvation. However, it most certainly has an affect upon your peace of mind and your eternal security.

If you believe that you will have to suffer horrible wraths, the same as those who deny God, for seven years -- would you have any peace of mind? No, you would be too busy worrying about the terrible wraths you will have to suffer.

Y'all come back now, ya heah?

Bill


Wow.. you must love the sound of your own voice (figuratively, of course)

sorry.. i asked a simple question. i got VP's answer, i got your answer. i snipped out all of the unnecessary stuff that wasn't a part of the question i asked.

oddly enough, to that exact question, you and VP have the same opinion.

if you're saved, whether or not there is a rapture won't make any diff in the end.

all the other stuff that you wrote that i snipped and that you jammed back in, while it might add flavor to the answer, it wasn't the answer. which is why i snipped it.

it wasn't tunnel vision, it was focus lol. i wanted an answer. i got my answer and disreguarded the filler you stuck in.
quote:
oddly enough, to that exact question, you and VP have the same opinion.

if you're saved, whether or not there is a rapture won't make any diff in the end.



Yes- I guess we do on the first part, but the huge difference is that Bill thinks that you are saved Once, and are "good to go".
When people ask me (being Catholic) if I have been saved, my reply is I have been saved, I am being saved, and praying that I will be saved in the future.
That's the major divider, I guess. I personally don't care much for end times discussions, as I really prefer to live in the now. Smiler
quote:
Originally posted by vplee123:
quote:
oddly enough, to that exact question, you and VP have the same opinion.

if you're saved, whether or not there is a rapture won't make any diff in the end.



Yes- I guess we do on the first part, but the huge difference is that Bill thinks that you are saved Once, and are "good to go".
When people ask me (being Catholic) if I have been saved, my reply is I have been saved, I am being saved, and praying that I will be saved in the future.
That's the major divider, I guess. I personally don't care much for end times discussions, as I really prefer to live in the now. Smiler



Sure.. Christ has Died, Christ has rosen, Christ will come again. Peace be with you.
etc etc. i have some issues with the catholic church, but i have no problem with catholics.

re: End Times - To debate and discuss?
Nah, me either, really. there's no point. the best we can do is the best we can do, and what happens isn't going to change. His Will Be Done, regardless of what i think about it.

However, it is sometimes fun to just speculate, with all parties knowing that it's just wild speculation.. a huge game of 'What If...".
quote:
Originally posted by Bill Gray:
Hi VP and Nagel,

So, the Bible is only a book of "What if?"?

I am sure that God will be interested to know this. He will probably thank you for telling Him that He authored a fairy tale "What if?" book.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill


I'm sure God knew it long long before i brought it up on here.

I have already told you that i do not believe that the majority of the bible remains as God's words.
i don't have a problem with the majority of the new testament, most of it is just 4 stories recounting the same event.
what i have trouble believing is the majority of the old testament.
i lean towards believing that what God wanted to tell us was corrupted by the greedy petty desires of power hungry leaders.

what better way to make your people obey your every little whim and fancy than to make your wishes seem to have come from God?

I know you disagree, but it doesn't matter to me that you do. We were given free will to do with as we please.

what i wonder is what God will say to the people down here who are preaching the words of twisted men long dead as HIS gospel.
quote:
Originally posted by vplee123:
quote:
all parties knowing that it's just wild speculation.. a huge game of 'What If...".


Yep. except when some parties don't believe it to be speculation, and throw around theories as though they are fact- then I take a bit of issue.
Peace be with you too. Smiler


Yeah... i'm begining to think that Our Bill has a total lack of any capability for even a hint of an imagination any more.
He's got his consumed entirely with "knowing' things that there is no way to know.

i'm with you on that one. i don't KNOW god is real, but i believe he is. i've felt something that is proof to me, but since i know that it could not be proof to anyone else, then i have no demonstrable proof, so it remains only my belief.
how can something be Proof of anything if you can't use it to prove it to anyone else?

the grass in my yard is green. see? here is a sample.
that's proof.
[Quote by bill Gray] I am not sure what book you mean. The only book I need is the Bible. I will often refer to commentaries just to get a flavor of what Bible scholars and theologians think about a particular Scripture verse or passage. But, ultimately, my interpretation comes from my own reading and study of the Bible.

I am talking about the Creed Book or I believe that is what the Baptists call it, anyway it tells you what you can believe.

And I am an Amillennialist,

VP asks about when his Kingdom will be established? we are living in his Kingdom now, the Church Established on the day of pentecost Acts chapter 2, Mark 9:1 And he said unto them, Verily I say unto you, There are some here of them that stand by , who shall in no wise taste of death, till they see the kingdom of God come with power. the Church, if this is wrong then there is some 2000 year old People out there somewhere still waiting.
Last edited by prince albert
The End of Times has been nigh since the earliest church of Jesus. There will be one, and it might come about by the actions of the religious, but its not predictable by the Bible.

C.S. Lewis once commented that Jesus, by his words, was either insane or truly the son of God. Jesus preached an immediate End of Times.

Poor Lewis, the SOB never could finish a thought. He went with the "son of god" ending, thinking Jesus could never be insane. Let's hope he'd have more courage and wisdom now.

Jim Jones. David Koresh. Charlemagne. Bo and Peep. Osama bin Laden. This is an incomplete list of men who've motivated their flocks to suicide and murder to prove their faith. It's madness, and you know it. The Christian apologists who say the early saints must have been right because they gave their lives for their beliefs have blocked out the obvious psychology that a certain amount of people will believe anything to the death, given a charismatic preacher.

Skepticism would have saved the lives of thousands.
quote:
Originally posted by Billy Joe Bob Gene:
The End of Times has been nigh since the earliest church of Jesus. There will be one, and it might come about by the actions of the religious, but its not predictable by the Bible.


that's acctually exactly correct, and something i DO think the bible got right. it says that the end will come like a thief in the night, and no one will be able predict it's coming.

which means to me - if you are expecting it, it isn't going to happen.

quote:

Jim Jones. David Koresh. Charlemagne. Bo and Peep. Osama bin Laden. This is an incomplete list of men who've motivated their flocks to suicide and murder to prove their faith. It's madness, and you know it. The Christian apologists who say the early saints must have been right because they gave their lives for their beliefs have blocked out the obvious psychology that a certain amount of people will believe anything to the death, given a charismatic preacher.


lets not forget the whackos who got new shoes and suits and .. whacko'd bits off and killed themselves to hitch a ride on the space ship that was in the comet's tail.

this is my problem with "Religion".
religions use the name of a diety to slaughter, maim, torture, enslave and subjugate and brainwash. every ' religion' on the planet is guilty of one or more of these at some point.
it's one of the reasons i have no dealings with religion.

quote:

Skepticism would have saved the lives of thousands.


Millions.
quote:
Originally posted by prince albert:
I am talking about the Creed Book or I believe that is what the Baptists call it, anyway it tells you what you can believe.

Hi Albert,

I have been in the Baptist church since I was saved in 1987, mostly Baptist General Conference (BGC), but a few years in Southern Baptist churches. And, I have never heard of such a book. The only book we recognize as having authority is the Bible.

As I said, I do read commentaries and other books, to get a flavor of the thinking of Bible scholars and theologians. But, the only book which has any authority, the only book I turn to for a final answer -- is the Bible.

Take care, my Friend.

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

Bill

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 0_-_CROSS-BIBLE_SAID-IT-1c
It's all in the interpretation. You can make it mean anything you want.

Here's my interpretation so far based on what I've read here in these forums-Check this out:

What Are The Three most Important Words Ever Spoken In Human History?



"Those ain't raisins!"


God is dead but He won't lie down. At least, that's what the Christian Coalition and all the other remaining Nazi splinter groups want you to believe. Satan LOVES a good BARBECUE!

Why not vote SOCIALIST this year?

"Never before, and never again, will I love you with the intensity of a shepherd for his flock." (Galatians 13:4)

"Hezekiah, get the babies off of me." (Job 14-7)

YES! DO YOU BELIEVE IT? We sure wouldn't buy it. But if YOU believe, then SCREW IT!

"Hey, somebody fetch that tit weasel!" (Exodus 19-12)

For it is written, HERE ON THIS VERY PAGE, "Everyone fools their own darn selves, except for the leper."

"We don't got no more whiskey. F@(% off!" (Ephesians 24:24)

Say this prayer out loud RIGHT NOW to a total stranger: "Please help me, I want to die. I want the hurting to stop. Oh God, get the metal filings out of my head. Oh God! I haven't seen the electric shock therapist for two days now. They'll be looking for me soon. Will you help me find my pretty Evelyn? I have to save her before the androids come. Stop thinking at me you rat bastid!"

There. Now doesn't that feel better?

Rev. Burfoot W. Smacknuggets,
Church of the Tangerine Ox

Unifield Theory Ministries
Newark, DE 19711

Tract No. 14 (in a series of 6)
quote:
Originally posted by Road Puppy:
It's all in the interpretation. You can make it mean anything you want.

Here's my interpretation so far based on what I've read here in these forums-Check this out:

What Are The Three most Important Words Ever Spoken In Human History?



"Those ain't raisins!"


God is dead but He won't lie down. At least, that's what the Christian Coalition and all the other remaining Nazi splinter groups want you to believe. Satan LOVES a good BARBECUE!

Why not vote SOCIALIST this year?

"Never before, and never again, will I love you with the intensity of a shepherd for his flock." (Galatians 13:4)

"Hezekiah, get the babies off of me." (Job 14-7)

YES! DO YOU BELIEVE IT? We sure wouldn't buy it. But if YOU believe, then SCREW IT!

"Hey, somebody fetch that tit weasel!" (Exodus 19-12)

For it is written, HERE ON THIS VERY PAGE, "Everyone fools their own darn selves, except for the leper."

"We don't got no more whiskey. F@(% off!" (Ephesians 24:24)

Say this prayer out loud RIGHT NOW to a total stranger: "Please help me, I want to die. I want the hurting to stop. Oh God, get the metal filings out of my head. Oh God! I haven't seen the electric shock therapist for two days now. They'll be looking for me soon. Will you help me find my pretty Evelyn? I have to save her before the androids come. Stop thinking at me you rat bastid!"

There. Now doesn't that feel better?

Rev. Burfoot W. Smacknuggets,
Church of the Tangerine Ox

Unifield Theory Ministries
Newark, DE 19711

Tract No. 14 (in a series of 6)


OMFG
you just made me shoot iced tea out both nostrils.
i literally got up and went and fetched my wife form he other room just so i could read this to her.. this is AWSOME

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×