Skip to main content

I am a local resident with 20 years of military service. I have paid Alabama state taxes for the last 20 years, even though my children has never attended school in the state, My family don't travel the roads and highways. For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen. Don't be confused, I'm really not complaining, because I could have changed my legal resident to a state without taxes,but I felt like I would be selling out my state. I love the state of Alabama and will be moving back there upon retiring from the military. My question to you is: Should a person in my situation qualify for Tax Free license plates after retiring?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
Originally posted by Strawberri:
I am a local resident with 20 years of military service. I have paid Alabama state taxes for the last 20 years, even though my children has never attended school in the state, My family don't travel the roads and highways. For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen. Don't be confused, I'm really not complaining, because I could have changed my legal resident to a state without taxes,but I felt like I would be selling out my state. I love the state of Alabama and will be moving back there upon retiring from the military. My question to you is: Should a person in my situation qualify for Tax Free license plates after retiring?


You say, "For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen." Well, if you were stationed outside of Alabama and drove your car on the roads of some other state or nation or received police protection and other public services in some other state or nation or had other public benefits in some other state or nation, you were receiving taxpayer-paid benefits that you paid no income tax on. So maybe you did not receive these benefits in Alabama, but you DID receive them, and SOMEONE ELSE's income taxes in some other state or nation paid for those benefits for you while you were living out of the state of Alabama. Thus is makes sense that you are--as you say--not complaining. My point is that you did not suffer from want of taxpayer-funded benefits, irrespective of your various places of residency during your military service.
quote:
Originally posted by Strawberri:
I am a local resident with 20 years of military service. I have paid Alabama state taxes for the last 20 years, even though my children has never attended school in the state, My family don't travel the roads and highways. For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen. Don't be confused, I'm really not complaining, because I could have changed my legal resident to a state without taxes,but I felt like I would be selling out my state. I love the state of Alabama and will be moving back there upon retiring from the military. My question to you is: Should a person in my situation qualify for Tax Free license plates after retiring?


Your question is Should a person in my situation qualify for Tax Free license plates after retiring? Should you? Yes. Will you I don't think so. I know my father-in-law has to pay taxes on his tag and he is military retired.

I scanned this page and didn't find an answer. Maybe it will help you if you look at it closer than I did.

LINK
quote:
Originally posted by beternU:
quote:
Originally posted by Strawberri:
I am a local resident with 20 years of military service. I have paid Alabama state taxes for the last 20 years, even though my children has never attended school in the state, My family don't travel the roads and highways. For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen. Don't be confused, I'm really not complaining, because I could have changed my legal resident to a state without taxes,but I felt like I would be selling out my state. I love the state of Alabama and will be moving back there upon retiring from the military. My question to you is: Should a person in my situation qualify for Tax Free license plates after retiring?


You say, "For the last 20 years I haven't benefited from anything that comes from being a citizen." Well, if you were stationed outside of Alabama and drove your car on the roads of some other state or nation or received police protection and other public services in some other state or nation or had other public benefits in some other state or nation, you were receiving taxpayer-paid benefits that you paid no income tax on. So maybe you did not receive these benefits in Alabama, but you DID receive them, and SOMEONE ELSE's income taxes in some other state or nation paid for those benefits for you while you were living out of the state of Alabama. Thus is makes sense that you are--as you say--not complaining. My point is that you did not suffer from want of taxpayer-funded benefits, irrespective of your various places of residency during your military service.


When I deployed overseas my transportation was a military vehicle and I was responsible for my own protection as well as others. In other host nations which house large American military installations such as Ramstein AB, Germany, there’s no telling how much revenue in taxes/leases/employment they generate.

So I’m not sure where you’re coming from, betternU. Are you saying the American service members serving overseas should be thankful to the taxpayers of those host nations for road use and police protection? Seems to me the benefits are on the other foot.

But do I feel Strawberri or I am entitled to a free Alabama retired vet vehicle tag? Not really. There are those who are far more deserving such as a combat disabled vet. I feel that it’s enough Alabama does not tax my retirement income. And there are states that do. But military retirement is not the only retirement not taxed by Alabama.
I don't wish to derail this subject but would like to bring up a point or two.
Budsfarm stated; But do I feel Strawberri or I am entitled to a free Alabama retired vet vehicle tag? Not really. There are those who are far more deserving such as a combat disabled vet.
A disabled vet (as determined by the VA) can receive a free disabled vet tag, but it is only the cost of the tag. You still have to pay the tax.
Now let me ask, how many of you know that if a vet has a disability related to their service will receive monetary compensation from the VA in accordance with the percentage of their disability as determined by the VA?
Second, how many realize that if the vet retired from the military, every thing the VA pays them for their disability is subtracted from their retirement pay?
How is it fair that a vet that served (say 4 years) and got out receives pay for a 20% disability (a little over $300/mo and doesn't have to give up anything but if the vet retired, they have to pay the same money out of their retirement pay.
The 4year vet is ahead $300 tax free, but the retired vet only gets out of paying taxes on his $300 that he/she has to give up out of their retirement pay.

In the 70's when vet were unpopular, no one seemed to care about the vet's but now days people seem to be more appreciative of those that has served to protect their freedom. I and many other vets would ask that if you rely mean it when (like “thenagel” said “And while we're here, Thank you, Strawberri.”) please talk to your congressperson.

For those that have fought for it, freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.
quote:
Originally posted by oLDsEAdADDY:
I don't wish to derail this subject but would like to bring up a point or two.
Budsfarm stated; But do I feel Strawberri or I am entitled to a free Alabama retired vet vehicle tag? Not really. There are those who are far more deserving such as a combat disabled vet.
A disabled vet (as determined by the VA) can receive a free disabled vet tag, but it is only the cost of the tag. You still have to pay the tax.
Now let me ask, how many of you know that if a vet has a disability related to their service will receive monetary compensation from the VA in accordance with the percentage of their disability as determined by the VA?
Second, how many realize that if the vet retired from the military, every thing the VA pays them for their disability is subtracted from their retirement pay?
How is it fair that a vet that served (say 4 years) and got out receives pay for a 20% disability (a little over $300/mo and doesn't have to give up anything but if the vet retired, they have to pay the same money out of their retirement pay.
The 4year vet is ahead $300 tax free, but the retired vet only gets out of paying taxes on his $300 that he/she has to give up out of their retirement pay.

In the 70's when vet were unpopular, no one seemed to care about the vet's but now days people seem to be more appreciative of those that has served to protect their freedom. I and many other vets would ask that if you rely mean it when (like “thenagel” said “And while we're here, Thank you, Strawberri.”) please talk to your congressperson.

For those that have fought for it, freedom has a flavor that the protected will never know.


The law has been changed for retired vets with 50% or more disability. They can now get both retirement and VA benefits.

http://www.military.com/benefi...ent-receipt-overview

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×