Ignorance is absolutely RAMPANT in this discussion. Those who assert that whooping cranes would adapt know absolutely nothing aout migratory activity of this species. They are nothing like caribou, which never have been endangered and which are distributed over thousands of square miles. To blithely suggest that they would adapt to the destruction of their very limited wintering habitat if it were converted to a refinery is asinine, scientifically indefensible and nothing short of anti-environmental knee-jerk blithering.
In all the discussion of offshore drilling, nothing on this string has touched upon the constant involvement of REPUBLICANS, including both Bush presidents and Republican Senator Mel Martinez, as well as formerRepublican Governor Jeb Bush, in impeding drilling off the Florida coast; Consider the information below and then get yourselves straight on just WHO is involved in all this:
"Florida's Annual Legislative Offshore Drilling Moratorium, Protection Renewed Each Year:
The Southwest coast of Florida, South of 26 degrees North Latitude, has long been protected by an annual "rider", or Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) Moratorium, that must be renewed yearly or it will expire on October 1 of any given year.
The President's new White House budget, released in January of 2005, includes a proposal to continue this protection through fiscal year 2006 (until October 1, 2006) although the Interior Appropriations bill, on which this rider must pass, has not yet been initiated in the Subcommittee on Interior Appropriations of the House Appropriations Committee. The same annual congressional OCS Moratorium that protects Florida's Southwest coastline also precludes new offshore oil and gas leasing along the U.S. West Coast and the entire Eastern Seaboard on a year-by-year basis.
Florida's Presidential Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) Leasing Deferrals until 2012:
During 1990, a yearlong study by the National Research Council (NRC) of the prestigious National Academy of Sciences found that insufficient scientific data existed to enable offshore drilling to proceed within the annual congressional OCS Moratorium areas while ensuring that the environment would be protected. Having commissioned this scientific study by the NRC, former President George Bush, Sr., became known as the "Environmental President" in 1991 when he issued his Executive OCS Deferrals, declaring that the existing Moratorium waters, with the exception of Bristol Bay in Alaska, would not be offered for new offshore oil and gas leasing until at least 2002.
During 1998, at a "Year of the Ocean" ceremony in Monterey, California, then-President Bill Clinton extended the duration of these same Executive OCS Deferrals until 2012. The current President George Bush, for the past four years, has repeatedly restated his support for both the annual legislative OCS Moratorium, and for sustaining the Executive OCS Deferrals until 2012. Immediately prior to the U.S. Senate debate on opening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas drilling, Interior Secretary Gale Norton once again restated the continuing support of the Administration for the legislative OCS Moratorium and the Executive OCS Deferrals in her March 16, 2005 letter to Senator Mel Martinez of Florida, although this letter does not contain any new assurances of any additional protection for Florida's coastline beyond what had already existed beforehand.
The Jeb Bush/George Bush "Compromise" Agreement of 2002, Deferring Offshore Drilling off of the Florida Panhandle for Ten Years (until 2012):
During May of 2002, Florida Governor Jeb Bush and his brother President George Bush reached a highly-publicized $235 million OCS agreement that was to lead to the buyback of 9 of a total of 11 leased-but-undeveloped offshore natural gas tracts along the Florida Panhandle, as well as result in the buyback and cancellation of certain onshore oil and gas leases in Big Cypress National Preserve, Florida Panther NWR, and Ten Thousand Islands NWR. Existing petroleum industry offshore leases on two of the most highly prospective natural gas tracts on Destin Dome, off of Pensacola, Florida, were not actually "relinquished"- or bought back by the federal government - at this time, although the State of Florida was assured by the Interior Department that it would have near-veto authority over any subsequent federal decision to develop and drill on these OCS tracts, which in any event would not occur for at least ten years from the date of the agreement (until 2012).
No New Protections in Interior Secretary Gale Norton's March 16 Letter to Senator Mel Martinez:
Because of the existing 1991 Executive OCS Deferrals put in place by President Bush, Sr., and the subsequent 2002 Jeb Bush/George Bush "Compromise" Agreement, both already in force, no offshore lease tracts within 100-miles of the Florida coastline have been included in the current Department of Interior Five-Year OCS Leasing Program for the period from 2002 to 2007. And no offshore oil and gas lease tracts within 100 miles of the Florida coastline could be put into the new Department of Interior Five-Year OCS Leasing Program now being planned for the period from 2007 through 2012. The March 16, 2005 letter from Interior Secretary Gale Norton to Senator Mel Martinez simply restates this pre-existing fact, adding no new protection to any area, nor adding any additional years of protection to that which was already in place for Florida's coast.
Perhaps Senator Mel Martinez said it best: "Look, it's give an inch and take a mile with these folks….. at this point, nothing Floridians offer in exchange for permanent control over our own waters will ever be enough for the pro-drilling interests. They will always want more. That's why we need to stand firm in maintaining all current protections off Florida's coast."
Are all these Republicans a bunch of environmental obstructionist tree-huggers?
Here is he link to the full item:
http://www.sierraclub.org/wildlands/coasts/ocs/florida.aspAs additional information, I do NOT oppose offshore drilling in Florida and California waters. The oil and gas industry has demonstrated their capability to drill responsibly in those kinds of waters.