Skip to main content

I think it's curious that most Protestants can't agree on certain interpretations

of the Bible. The very thing they believe is their authority. I would think all

Protestants would agree that there's only one truth and that wouldn't be

subjective. The heated discussion I just saw between two Protestants says

it all when it comes to every person for themselves without some type of

authority besides a book that can be twisted any way anyone wants it.

 

Jesus didn't say on this bible I'm going to build my Church. He did say

he wanted unity.

 

John 17: 13-22

13

But now I am coming to you. I speak this in the world so that they may share my joy completely.

14

I gave them your word, and the world hated them, because they do not belong to the world any more than I belong to the world.

15

I do not ask that you take them out of the world but that you keep them from the evil one.

16

They do not belong to the world any more than I belong to the world.

17

Consecrate them in the truth. Your word is truth.

18

As you sent me into the world, so I sent them into the world.

19

And I consecrate myself for them, so that they also may be consecrated in truth.

20

"I pray not only for them, but also for those who will believe in me through their word,

21

so that they may all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be in us, that the world may believe that you sent me.

22

And I have given them the glory you gave me, so that they may be one, as we are one,

 

 

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Vic, my Friend,

 

Not sure what point you are trying to make.  Yes, we do have different Bible translations.  Yes, we do often differ in our interpretations of some points of Scripture.  Yes, some people have so twisted Scripture that they have created cult churches.

 

And, there are churches which want to relegate the Bible to a lesser authority -- while elevating their sacred book or traditions to a position of higher authority.

 

Two examples I can easily give you are (1) the Mormon church with their Book of Mormon, and (2) the Roman Catholic church with its Traditions, Catechisms, and Papal writings.

 

You may say that is not true about the Roman Catholic church.  But, any time we see the Bible in conflict with your Traditions -- your Traditions always trump the Bible, in your view.

 

 A great example is the Roman Catholic church's insistence upon forcing the Apocrypha INTO the Bible -- when most will admit that is not canon.

 

Jesus tells us in Scripture:

 

John 10:9-10, "I am the door; if anyone enters through Me, he will be saved, and will go in and out and find pasture.  The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I came that they may have life, and have it abundantly."

 

You tell us that Jesus came that we might have unity.   Not so!   He came that we might have life -- eternal spiritual life!   That was His one and only reason for coming to earth as God Incarnate.

 

So, once again, I ask you:  What is your point in starting this discussion?

 

You have stated before that you often post discussions -- JUST to start an argument.  Is that your purpose here?

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

1 - Bible_Open-FAMILY-GROW

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1 - Bible_Open-FAMILY-GROW

.

billieee said

You may say that is not true about the Roman Catholic church.  But, any time we see the Bible in conflict with your Traditions -- your Traditions always trump the Bible, in your view.

 

The Bible is the Truth and no Catholic Dogma or tradition will contradict it,

but Catholics do not believe that it is the authority. Otherwise there would

have been no authority for the first 400 years of the Church.

You have learned more from Catholic Traditions, Catechism, Papal writings

and online sites, when they are real sites, not your chuck smith

BS than you'll ever admit. 

 

You tell us that Jesus came that we might have unity.   Not so!   He came that we might have life -- eternal spiritual life!   That was His one and only reason for coming to earth as God Incarnate.

 

I said Jesus wanted us to have Unity. You said Jesus was a liar.

Jesus came to earth to atone for the sin of Adam and reopen the gates of

heaven. That was to give us a chance for Heaven. We still earn it or we lose

it. You still dream of the cowards way to Heaven with your osas lie.

Will never happen.

 

And I didn't start this post to talk to you anyway. You just butt in with a

suck azz attitude like you know something. You don't.

Last edited by INVICTUS

Vic, my Friend,

 

You tell me, "The Bible is the Truth and no Catholic Dogma or tradition will contradict it, but Catholics do not believe that it is the authority."

 

So, if the Bible is not the authority for God's body of believers, the church -- then WHAT IS the authority?   Something has to the highest authority, to guide the body of Christ.  So, if not the Bible, then what?   The Roman Catholic church?  The Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?  What is the authority, my Friend?

 

If you say the Roman Catholic church Traditions and Dogmas are the authority; then you are agreeing with me.  So, what do you say -- the Bible OR Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?

 

The rest of your post speaks volumes regarding your immaturity.

 

Bless your heart!

 

Bill

Bible - 66 BOOKS

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Bible - 66 BOOKS
Originally Posted by Bill Gray:

Vic, my Friend,

 

You tell me, "The Bible is the Truth and no Catholic Dogma or tradition will contradict it, but Catholics do not believe that it is the authority."

 

So, if the Bible is not the authority for God's body of believers, the church -- then WHAT IS the authority?   Something has to the highest authority, to guide the body of Christ.  So, if not the Bible, then what?   The Roman Catholic church?  The Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?  What is the authority, my Friend?

 

If you say the Roman Catholic church Traditions and Dogmas are the authority; then you are agreeing with me.  So, what do you say -- the Bible OR Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?

 

The rest of your post speaks volumes regarding your immaturity.

 

.

.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

One thing is for sure, I've not posted anything in the last few years that you

have discussed. You whine, criticize, redirect the subject, lie, slander me,

rant, panic, more lies and the most egregious sub human I've ever ran into.

I'm not alone in this which shows you are an equal opportunity piece of s***.

 

You call your book the Holy Bible. It isn't, its been mutilated and redefined

by a sinner guilty of the desecration of the sacred scripture given to us by

the Holy Spirit. I know that doesn't matter to you as long as you have your

abridged and raped unholy book you worship in your unholy cult.

 

As a Catholic I recognize the highest authority being the Holy Trinity.

The Supremacy of God is higher than your bible book whether you like

it or not.  

 

I, in no way beyond this point see the need nor the reason to continue

scrapping the s*** off my shoes from a walk with you down Hell's Calvinist

and sacrilegious life. So, would you excuse me.

 

Vic, my Friend,

 

We agree that God: Father, Son, Holy Spirit is the highest authority for mankind.

 

However, God has given us two teachers:  the Holy Spirit and His Written Word, the Bible.

 

So, if the Bible AND Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas differ -- which one will you accept as being correct and being the highest authority?  Which will you say is wrong when the two differ?

 

And, they do differ, many times.  So, what say you:  Bible -- OR -- Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?

 

Now, you can give a straightforward answer -- OR -- you can resort to your typical response and call me names.  Of course, when you take the latter avenue, calling me names, that only shows that you cannot give a straightforward answer -- and have to sink to name calling.

 

So, which is it:  an answer -- OR -- name calling?

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

1 - Bible_Open-FAMILY-GROW

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 1 - Bible_Open-FAMILY-GROW
Originally Posted by INVICTUS:
Originally Posted by Bill Gray:

Vic, my Friend,

 

You tell me, "The Bible is the Truth and no Catholic Dogma or tradition will contradict it, but Catholics do not believe that it is the authority."

 

So, if the Bible is not the authority for God's body of believers, the church -- then WHAT IS the authority?   Something has to the highest authority, to guide the body of Christ.  So, if not the Bible, then what?   The Roman Catholic church?  The Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?  What is the authority, my Friend?

 

If you say the Roman Catholic church Traditions and Dogmas are the authority; then you are agreeing with me.  So, what do you say -- the Bible OR Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?

 

The rest of your post speaks volumes regarding your immaturity.

 

.

.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

One thing is for sure, I've not posted anything in the last few years that you

have discussed. You whine, criticize, redirect the subject, lie, slander me,

rant, panic, more lies and the most egregious sub human I've ever ran into.

I'm not alone in this which shows you are an equal opportunity piece of s***.

 

You call your book the Holy Bible. It isn't, its been mutilated and redefined

by a sinner guilty of the desecration of the sacred scripture given to us by

the Holy Spirit. I know that doesn't matter to you as long as you have your

abridged and raped unholy book you worship in your unholy cult.

 

As a Catholic I recognize the highest authority being the Holy Trinity.

The Supremacy of God is higher than your bible book whether you like

it or not.  

 

I, in no way beyond this point see the need nor the reason to continue

scrapping the s*** off my shoes from a walk with you down Hell's Calvinist

and sacrilegious life. So, would you excuse me.

 

.

That's the truth of the matter and I'm sticking to it

Vic, my Friend,

 

Not a problem!  I realize there will always be folks like you who are not mature enough to enter into a civil, intelligent, productive discussion.   So, you will just continue to regurgitate whatever seeps into your mind.

 

Sad, but understandable.   Some folks never will mature.

 

Bless your little heart!

 

Bill

Originally Posted by INVICTUS:
Originally Posted by INVICTUS:
Originally Posted by Bill Gray:

Vic, my Friend,

 

You tell me, "The Bible is the Truth and no Catholic Dogma or tradition will contradict it, but Catholics do not believe that it is the authority."

 

So, if the Bible is not the authority for God's body of believers, the church -- then WHAT IS the authority?   Something has to the highest authority, to guide the body of Christ.  So, if not the Bible, then what?   The Roman Catholic church?  The Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?  What is the authority, my Friend?

 

If you say the Roman Catholic church Traditions and Dogmas are the authority; then you are agreeing with me.  So, what do you say -- the Bible OR Roman Catholic Traditions and Dogmas?

 

The rest of your post speaks volumes regarding your immaturity.

 

.

.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

One thing is for sure, I've not posted anything in the last few years that you

have discussed. You whine, criticize, redirect the subject, lie, slander me,

rant, panic, more lies and the most egregious sub human I've ever ran into.

I'm not alone in this which shows you are an equal opportunity piece of s***.

 

You call your book the Holy Bible. It isn't, its been mutilated and redefined

by a sinner guilty of the desecration of the sacred scripture given to us by

the Holy Spirit. I know that doesn't matter to you as long as you have your

abridged and raped unholy book you worship in your unholy cult.

 

As a Catholic I recognize the highest authority being the Holy Trinity.

The Supremacy of God is higher than your bible book whether you like

it or not.  

 

I, in no way beyond this point see the need nor the reason to continue

scrapping the s*** off my shoes from a walk with you down Hell's Calvinist

and sacrilegious life. So, would you excuse me.

 

.

That's the truth of the matter and I'm sticking to it

 

Vic, my Friend,

 

NO problem!  Just continue to regurgitate whatever is in your soul -- as you do when you just copy/paste your own writings.  Funny though.   YOU are the only person I know who plagiarizes himself!   Now, that has to be some kind of record.

 

And, my Friend, if you ever realize that you have no relationship with Jesus Christ -- then maybe you will realize your need to get into His Word, the Bible.   And, He does not mind you plagiarizing Him at all.  Matter of fact, He encourages it.  That should make YOU feel very welcome!

 

Bless your little plagiarized heart!

 

Bill

Almost Believer

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Almost Believer

Hi David,

 

But, what is the purpose of just copy/pasting his exact same post -- with nothing added -- when the original is already just above?   It is childish and makes no sense.  It seems that he is just having a childish tantrum, determined to have the last word -- but, without the ability to think of anything new to write.

 

He has stated before that he will post 100% copy/paste of articles he has found on Google -- in an attempt to start an argument.  Seems like that is what he is doing when he just reposts his previous post.

 

If he has something new to add to a discussion, that is welcomed.  But, if he cannot think of something new to add, then he needs to be quiet and lets the adults converse.

 

Let me ask you:  Do YOU see any true purpose or reason for him posting the same thing over and over?

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

Hi David,

 

I have seen Vic do that 3, 4, 5 times -- always just copy/pasting the same thing over and over and over.   Does his post become more true, or false, the more times he copy/pastes it?

 

David, I realize that you want to defend Vic because you consider him a Roman Catholic.  But, if you would be honest with yourself -- you and I both know that his actions on the Religion Forum are an embarrassment to your church.

 

I have been having discussions with Roman Catholic Friends, both on Facebook and in my Friends Ministry eNewsletter, for years -- and I have never seen any Roman Catholic cast such a negative image on your church as he does.

 

I would love to have civil, constructive dialogues with him, you, and others on the forum.  And, for the most part, you and I do have good dialogues.  To have a good dialogue does not mean that we have to agree with one another.  We can, when necessary, disagree -- and still remain civil and have productive discussions.

 

But, with Vic, that is not possible -- for he would rather cast aspersions -- than have a discussion.

 

So, in summary, maybe repeating the same thing once, occasionally, for emphasis -- can be productive.  But, how productive is it -- if done 3, 4, 5 times.  And, Vic has done that.

 

David, thank you.

 

God bless, have a wonderful, blessed day,

 

Bill

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×