Skip to main content

http://timesdaily.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/200701...01203350&cachetime=5

Why is it that when a woman commits a crime it is looked at differently than if a man had committed the same crime? If a man had starved his children to death the prosecution would settle for no less than the death penalty. I'm too lazy so you can do the research for the particulars but it seems like everytime we hear of a woman killing her kids she is pretty much guaranteed a stay in a mental institution. Now, I'm not going to get into a debate over the death penalty or whether or not someone is mentally incompetent but what I will debate is equal justice for all. Plenty will stand up for equal rights so what happens when it comes to crime and punishment?

As far as equal rights go, why does a man pay more for auto insurance than a woman of the same age with the same driving record?
------------------------------------ Romans 12:21 Do not be overcome by evil But overcome evil with good
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
Originally posted by drdemo35:

As far as equal rights go, why does a man pay more for auto insurance than a woman of the same age with the same driving record?


_______________________________________

I am not in the insurance business, nor have I done the research to know if your assumption is correct. If indeed it is, I would say that actuary science is your answer. In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.
quote:
In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.


Very true but there is an ongoing fight for equal rights so why not equal justice? A woman drowns her kids in the bathtub or runs her car off into the river with her children in it or starves her children to death and if there ever is a conviction it usually doesn't end in the death penalty. Instead there is always someone trying to get her off on insanity. Which, in itself, never made sense to me because in my opinion, anyone that commits a crime against another human being or even another living thing must be insane.
quote:
Originally posted by drdemo35:
quote:
In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.


Very true but there is an ongoing fight for equal rights so why not equal justice? A woman drowns her kids in the bathtub or runs her car off into the river with her children in it or starves her children to death and if there ever is a conviction it usually doesn't end in the death penalty. Instead there is always someone trying to get her off on insanity. Which, in itself, never made sense to me because in my opinion, anyone that commits a crime against another human being or even another living thing must be insane.


I got to heartily disagree with you on your opinion on insanity. There's lots of people out there who burglarize, rob, assault, rape, and kill other humans that are not even remotely close to insane, or even mentally off. They're just plain and ordinary junkyard dog mean. Lots of people try to rationalize that the bad guys "must be crazy or insane". It's just peoples way of saying, "I really live in a safe little world, and this is just a glitch, an error in somebody's mind. It will not happen again, because people just don't do that IF THEY ARE NORMAL". They need to wake up and smell the coffee....there are lots of people out there who don't meet the clinical or the legal definition of "insane"...but who will cut your throat or shoot you down for what you have in your pockets.

And, in line with the above thinking, it's a lot easier for most people to believe that a mother is insane than to believe that she could overcome her mothering instincts and harm her children. If they would look to the animal world, they would find that although offspring are guarded as best they can, if it comes down to the mother's life or the offspring, the offspring usually are going to die. Case in point...a whitetail deer can and will spontaneously self abort a fetus when a winter is too severe for her to survive carrying the fawn. She also will if a pack of dogs get after her and she feels her life is threatened. Also, a mother rabbit will eat her young if she is lacking the nutrition she needs to survive.

Finally, even in today's culture it's hard to get a conviction to sentence a woman to death. Juries just don't want to be the ones who sentenced a woman to die. Prosecutors are afraid that the jury will hand down a lesser included charge or find them not guilty, so they go for a sentence they feel that they can get (life without possibility of parole).
quote:
Originally posted by dbt123:
quote:
Originally posted by drdemo35:

As far as equal rights go, why does a man pay more for auto insurance than a woman of the same age with the same driving record?


_______________________________________

I am not in the insurance business, nor have I done the research to know if your assumption is correct. If indeed it is, I would say that actuary science is your answer. In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.


That is true in our BIG BUSINESS society, that is why the rich keep gettiing richer, exploiting women workers, and they hire boatloads because they KNOW they can get away with it... a lot of women just take it and say nothing for fear of losing their job....

But another point I strongly disagree about is where I work, it is UNION, and I am a female, I make the SAME as my male co-workers, I get the SAME pay raises, the SAME benefits. We have a lot of upper level managers that are women who make HUGE amounts of money. So that isn't the case everywhere.
quote:
Originally posted by stupid people suck:
What is the debate about women and men and the death penalty.We live in the bible belt and the bible say's (an eye for an eye)
It should not matter who did the crime if people lived by the bible as they claim to.


This is a great post, and I TOTALLY agree with you!!! Women should get the death penalty for killing the little ones who depend on HER for their very life... This woman should get the death penalty, no doubt in my mind, and I would'nt ever get picked for a jury like that because I think male or female, you kill your kid, you get the needle!!!!!

We just do NOT protect our children like we should. I am not talking about your children... I am talking about on the whole... men molest kids, plea agreement, out on the streets before you can bat an eye... men rape an adult female, they can get life in prison.

If any of those women who killed their children, had of killed adults, they would be on death row.

Our laws are unfair in the WRONG direction.
quote:
Originally posted by alacharger:
quote:
Originally posted by drdemo35:
quote:
In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.


Very true but there is an ongoing fight for equal rights so why not equal justice? A woman drowns her kids in the bathtub or runs her car off into the river with her children in it or starves her children to death and if there ever is a conviction it usually doesn't end in the death penalty. Instead there is always someone trying to get her off on insanity. Which, in itself, never made sense to me because in my opinion, anyone that commits a crime against another human being or even another living thing must be insane.


I got to heartily disagree with you on your opinion on insanity. There's lots of people out there who burglarize, rob, assault, rape, and kill other humans that are not even remotely close to insane, or even mentally off. They're just plain and ordinary junkyard dog mean. Lots of people try to rationalize that the bad guys "must be crazy or insane". It's just peoples way of saying, "I really live in a safe little world, and this is just a glitch, an error in somebody's mind. It will not happen again, because people just don't do that IF THEY ARE NORMAL". They need to wake up and smell the coffee....there are lots of people out there who don't meet the clinical or the legal definition of "insane"...but who will cut your throat or shoot you down for what you have in your pockets.

And, in line with the above thinking, it's a lot easier for most people to believe that a mother is insane than to believe that she could overcome her mothering instincts and harm her children. If they would look to the animal world, they would find that although offspring are guarded as best they can, if it comes down to the mother's life or the offspring, the offspring usually are going to die. Case in point...a whitetail deer can and will spontaneously self abort a fetus when a winter is too severe for her to survive carrying the fawn. She also will if a pack of dogs get after her and she feels her life is threatened. Also, a mother rabbit will eat her young if she is lacking the nutrition she needs to survive.

Finally, even in today's culture it's hard to get a conviction to sentence a woman to death. Juries just don't want to be the ones who sentenced a woman to die. Prosecutors are afraid that the jury will hand down a lesser included charge or find them not guilty, so they go for a sentence they feel that they can get (life without possibility of parole).


alacharger, very well thought out reply... thing is we need to make it EASIER to get a conviction on ANYONE who commits ANY crime against a child. Man, woman, next door neighbor... ANYONE who hurts a child should pay even MORE than if they hurt an adult. At least adults can defend themselves somewhat... Children are innocents, in every situation, they are innocents.. We HAVE to prod our lawmakers to make tougher laws so the Andrea Yates, Susan Smiths, and any other woman/man who murders their children to get the needle.

We need to make tougher laws for those who molest innocent, trusting children... we have to prod our elected officials to do their job, not take the easy way out...

Children are our future, we HAVE to protect them at all costs!!!
quote:
Originally posted by Kindred_Spirit:
quote:
Originally posted by alacharger:
quote:
Originally posted by drdemo35:
quote:
In the same line of thought, think about a woman and man with equal skills and job experience working in the same job position for the same company: many companies still pay women cents to the (man's) dollar.


Very true but there is an ongoing fight for equal rights so why not equal justice? A woman drowns her kids in the bathtub or runs her car off into the river with her children in it or starves her children to death and if there ever is a conviction it usually doesn't end in the death penalty. Instead there is always someone trying to get her off on insanity. Which, in itself, never made sense to me because in my opinion, anyone that commits a crime against another human being or even another living thing must be insane.


I got to heartily disagree with you on your opinion on insanity. There's lots of people out there who burglarize, rob, assault, rape, and kill other humans that are not even remotely close to insane, or even mentally off. They're just plain and ordinary junkyard dog mean. Lots of people try to rationalize that the bad guys "must be crazy or insane". It's just peoples way of saying, "I really live in a safe little world, and this is just a glitch, an error in somebody's mind. It will not happen again, because people just don't do that IF THEY ARE NORMAL". They need to wake up and smell the coffee....there are lots of people out there who don't meet the clinical or the legal definition of "insane"...but who will cut your throat or shoot you down for what you have in your pockets.

And, in line with the above thinking, it's a lot easier for most people to believe that a mother is insane than to believe that she could overcome her mothering instincts and harm her children. If they would look to the animal world, they would find that although offspring are guarded as best they can, if it comes down to the mother's life or the offspring, the offspring usually are going to die. Case in point...a whitetail deer can and will spontaneously self abort a fetus when a winter is too severe for her to survive carrying the fawn. She also will if a pack of dogs get after her and she feels her life is threatened. Also, a mother rabbit will eat her young if she is lacking the nutrition she needs to survive.

Finally, even in today's culture it's hard to get a conviction to sentence a woman to death. Juries just don't want to be the ones who sentenced a woman to die. Prosecutors are afraid that the jury will hand down a lesser included charge or find them not guilty, so they go for a sentence they feel that they can get (life without possibility of parole).


alacharger, very well thought out reply... thing is we need to make it EASIER to get a conviction on ANYONE who commits ANY crime against a child. Man, woman, next door neighbor... ANYONE who hurts a child should pay even MORE than if they hurt an adult. At least adults can defend themselves somewhat... Children are innocents, in every situation, they are innocents.. We HAVE to prod our lawmakers to make tougher laws so the Andrea Yates, Susan Smiths, and any other woman/man who murders their children to get the needle.

We need to make tougher laws for those who molest innocent, trusting children... we have to prod our elected officials to do their job, not take the easy way out...

Children are our future, we HAVE to protect them at all costs!!!
Sometimes I can't seem to say what it is that I am really thinking. On the insanity issue I say, what difference does it make if they are considered insane, cruel, twisted, evil, mean, etc. They should pay for these hideous crimes and male or female should be given the same sentence or, as some think, same chance at reform.


quote:
Originally posted by stupid people suck:
What is the debate about women and men and the death penalty.We live in the bible belt and the bible say's (an eye for an eye)
It should not matter who did the crime if people lived by the bible as they claim to.


Matthew 5:37-39 (Amplified Bible)
Amplified Bible (AMP)
Copyright © 1954, 1958, 1962, 1964, 1965, 1987 by The Lockman Foundation


37Let your Yes be simply Yes, and your No be simply No; anything more than that comes from the evil one.(A)

38You have heard that it was said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.(B)

39But I say to you, Do not resist the evil man [who injures you]; but if anyone strikes you on the right jaw or cheek, turn to him the other one too.

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×